Can you replace just the handle on a screen door?

Yes, it is possible to replace just the handle on a screen door. The handle is one of the most frequently used parts on a screen door and can wear out or break over time. Replacing just the handle is a relatively easy DIY project that can extend the life of your screen door.

Why Replace a Screen Door Handle

There are a few common reasons you may need to replace the handle on a screen door:

• The handle is loose or wobbly
• The handle is damaged, cracked, or broken
• You want to update the look with a new handle style or finish
• The spring or latch mechanism inside the handle stops working properly

A loose or damaged handle not only looks bad, but can make opening and closing the screen door difficult. Replacing just the handle is a quick and cost-effective solution.

How to Replace a Screen Door Handle

Replacing a screen door handle is a relatively simple project you can likely do yourself in about 10-15 minutes with basic tools.

Materials Needed

• New screen door handle
• Phillips head screwdriver
• Pliers or adjustable wrench

You’ll need to purchase a new handle specially designed for screen doors. Look for one that fits the existing screw holes on your door frame. Handles come in a variety of styles, materials like aluminum or brass, and finishes like black, bronze, or nickel.

Steps to Replace Screen Door Handle

Follow these steps to easily install a new screen door handle:

1. Remove the old handle. Locate the screws on the inside of the door frame holding the handle in place. Use a Phillips head screwdriver to remove the screws. The handle will then come free from the door.
2. Remove inner components. Grip the latch mechanism inside the door frame with pliers or a wrench and unscrew it. Remove any other internal components that come out with the handle.
3. Install new components. Insert any spring, latch, or other components into the door frame as per the manufacturer’s directions. Insert the new handle into the door and align the screw holes.
4. Secure new handle. Insert the handle screws into the pre-drilled holes and tighten them with a screwdriver until snug.
5. Test operation. Open and close the screen door a few times to ensure the handle, latch, and spring operate smoothly.

Be sure not to overtighten the screws when installing the new handle. Check that everything is aligned properly before tightening the screws down fully.

Troubleshooting Screen Door Handle Replacement

If you run into any issues replacing your screen door handle, here are some troubleshooting tips:

Handle is loose

• Tighten handle screws fully.
• Ensure screws are correct size for holes.
• Apply non-permanent threadlocker to screws.

Handle won’t latch properly

• Make sure spring and latch mechanism are installed correctly.
• Adjust strike plate on door jamb if needed.
• File down latch if sticking.

New handle doesn’t align right

• Adjust angle of handle to match previous handle angle.
• Redrill new screw holes if existing holes don’t line up.

Carefully following the manufacturer’s instructions can help avoid most issues when installing a new handle. Make adjustments to the components as needed to get proper alignment and operation.

When to Call a Professional

While a screen door handle replacement is quite straightforward for most DIYers, you may want to call in a handyman or contractor if:

• The handle screws are stripped or you can’t get the old handle off.
• The frame is damaged and no longer fits a standard handle.
• You need to cut into the door frame to install a new type of handle.
• You don’t feel comfortable replacing components like springs, rollers, or latches.

Hiring a professional ensures the job is done properly to restore full function to your screen door. They will have specialized tools and skills for removing stuck handles, modifying door frames, and troubleshooting other issues.

Cost to Replace a Screen Door Handle

If you DIY, the biggest cost is just buying the new handle hardware which may range from $10-50 depending on style and materials. Hiring a handyman will add $40-70 for labor.

Here are typical costs:

New screen door handle	$10-$50
Handyman installation labor	$40-$70
Total cost to replace	$50-$120

This provides a quick and affordable way to update an old or damaged handle and extend the life of your screen door.

How Long Does a Screen Door Handle Last?

With proper installation and maintenance, you can expect a screen door handle to last:

• 5-10 years for budget handles
• 10-15 years for mid-range handles
• 15-20+ years for high-end, solid brass handles

Handles that receive heavy use or are exposed to weather extremes may wear out more quickly. Higher quality materials generally provide greater longevity.

Signs Your Handle Needs Replacing

• Visible cracks, chips, dents, or corrosion
• Loose, wiggly handle
• Repeated sticking, catching, or rubbing
• Failure to latch or unlatch

At the first signs of issues, go ahead and replace the handle to restore smooth operation and prevent further damage.

How to Care for Your New Screen Door Handle

To maximize the longevity of your new handle, be sure to:

• Keep handle screws tightened to prevent looseness
• Lubricate latch mechanism with spray lubricant or silicone
• Seal any unfinished metal handles
• Avoid slamming or excessive force when opening
• Use handle properly, not to pull door open or hang items

Protecting the handle from direct exposure to rain and regular wear and tear will help prevent premature failure.

Best Materials for Screen Door Handles

The most durable options include:

Solid Brass

• Beautiful, classic appearance
• Naturally weather resistant
• Won’t rust, peel, or corrode
• Sturdy and secure feel
• Expensive but long lasting

Stainless Steel

• Sleek, modern aesthetic
• Good strength and durability
• Resists rust and corrosion
• Lower cost than brass
• Prone to dents and scratches

Cast Zinc Alloy

• Provides a solid, heavier feel
• More detail and ornamentation
• Often chrome or powder coated
• Prone to chipping
• Affordable option

Avoid cheaper plastic handles which can crack or warp over time. For strength, weather resistance, and classic style, solid brass is the top choice.

Matching Your New Handle Finish

Pick a handle finish that coordinates well with your existing door hardware and house exterior for the most cohesive look. Options include:

• Satin Nickel – Neutral tone pairs with most styles
• Oil Rubbed Bronze – Rich, dark brown works with brown doors
• Polished Chrome – Bright, modern appearance
• Antique Brass – Classic distressed golden hue
• Matte Black – Matches black framed doors and fixtures

Look at door knobs, house numbers, lighting fixtures, and other exterior hardware to determine the best finish match.

Replacing Screen Door Handle vs. Entire Door

If other components of your screen door are still in good condition, just replacing the handle is the most cost effective solution.

However, if your screen itself is ripped or sagging, the frame is bent, warped, or rusted, or you want to update your door’s size or style, it may be time for a whole new door.

When to Replace Entire Screen Door

• Screen mesh is badly ripped or has holes
• Frame is rusted, damaged, or rotting away
• Size, design, or features need updating
• You want to improve energy efficiency or soundproofing
• It will cost more to repair than replace door

A new screen door costs $100-$500+ professionally installed depending on size, style, and materials. This invests in improved security, curb appeal, and functionality.

Screen Door Handle Styles

Common handle designs include:

Simple Pull Handle

• Basic straight handle
• Typically same finish on both sides
• Pulls in, out, left, or right
• Usually budget-friendly

Decorative Pull Handle

• Stylized curves, scrolls, shapes
• Wrought iron or solid brass most common
• Coordinating interior and exterior
• Wide variety of antique, rustic looks

Knob Latch

• Interior knob with keyed exterior cylinder
• Provides added security
• Often on Dutch style screen doors
• Match knob to door knobs

Lever Latch Handle

• Curved interior lever, exterior plate
• Stylish on newer doors
• Available in many finishes
• Easy for children or elderly to operate

Measure your door thickness and hardware locations when selecting a new handle. Consider your home’s style, your needs, and your budget.

Handle Position: Pull Side vs. Push Side

Screen door handles come in different configurations depending on which side you will use to open the door:

Pull Side

• Handle is on exterior of door
• Pull handle towards you to open
• Interior side just has flat plate

Push Side

• Handle is on interior side of door
• Push handle away to open exterior
• Keyed lockset often on exterior

Choose whether you want to pull the handle or push it based on clearance, surrounding structures, and safety.

How to Measure for a New Screen Door Handle

To find an accurately sized replacement handle, you need to measure a few things:

Door Thickness

• Open door and use tape measure to measure thickness of door frame
• Common sizes are 1-1/4″, 1-3/8″, 1-1/2″, or 1-3/4″ thick
• Ensure new handle is made for your door thickness

Screw Hole Placement

• Determine horizontal x vertical screw hole spacing
• Standard is 2-3/4″ x 10-1/2″ or 2-3/8″ x 10″
• Measure spacing to get exact centers of your screw holes

Handle Length

• Measure old handle end to end
• Standard lengths are 8″, 10″, 12″
• Make sure new handle spans past screw holes

Getting accurate measurements ensures proper fit and easy, secure installation of your new handle. Take notes and bring them when shopping.

FAQs About Replacing Screen Door Handles

Why does my screen door handle keep falling off?

If the handle screws keep loosening causing the handle to detach, try using new longer screws, add washers, fill holes with toothpicks before re-screwing, or use threadlocker fluid to keep a tighter connection.

How do I get an old screen door handle off?

Remove any interior knob or lever first, then use a Phillips head screwdriver to remove the long exterior screws. You may need to spray lubricant or use pliers to pry it free if stuck.

Can I just replace the screen on my screen door?

Yes, you can purchase screen roll kits and splice in new screening material just on the damaged section or for the entire screen. New spline will secure it to the frame.

What size screws do I need for a screen door handle?

Most handles use #8 or #10 x 1-1/4″ to 2″ long Phillips head screws. Bring your old screws to ensure an exact match when buying replacements.

How do I tighten a loose screen door?

If hinges are loose, tighten all screws. For a loose screen frame, realign and tap spline into channel with screwdriver and mallet. Use additional spline or glue if needed.

Conclusion

Replacing just the worn or damaged handle is an easy and affordable way to update and extend the life of your screen door. Carefully measure your existing handle mount, choose a quality solid brass or stainless steel replacement handle in an attractive finish, and install it using proper screws. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for smooth operation. With just a little DIY experience, you can complete this project in under 30 minutes without having to purchase an entire new door.