Fake security cameras have become increasingly popular for homeowners and businesses looking for an affordable way to deter crime. Unlike real surveillance cameras, fake cameras don’t actually record, but they create the illusion of security. Proponents argue fake cameras provide a visual deterrent to make criminals think twice. But do fake security cameras really stop theft and burglary? Let’s examine the evidence.
Page Contents
- 1 What are fake security cameras?
- 2 Do fake cameras deter crime?
- 3 Evidence that fake cameras work
- 4 What makes an effective dummy camera?
- 5 Putting it together – tips for installing effective fake cameras
- 6 Downsides and risks of fake cameras
- 7 Are fake cameras illegal?
- 8 Should I choose real or fake security cameras?
- 9 Conclusion
What are fake security cameras?
Fake security cameras, also called dummy cameras, are designed to imitate real CCTV cameras. They have the same dome-shaped housing and distinctive design, but contain no actual recording function. The cameras don’t require wiring or WiFi connectivity. Many models include an LED light to mimic the “on” light found on real cameras. The intention is to trick potential intruders into believing they are being watched and recorded.
There are a wide variety of styles to choose from:
- Indoor cameras mounted on ceilings or walls
- Outdoor cameras with weatherproof housing
- Small, discreet “spy cameras” for covert locations
- Large, obvious cameras to serve as a visible deterrent
- Models with flashing LED lights for added realism
- Infrared cameras that give the impression of night vision
Prices range from about $6 for simple units to over $100 for more sophisticated models with multiple camera heads. Overall, fake security cameras provide the look of surveillance at a fraction of the cost of real camera systems. But do potential thieves know the difference?
Do fake cameras deter crime?
This is the critical question around dummy security cameras. Several factors point to fake cameras having at least some deterrent effect against residential and commercial theft:
Appearance of surveillance
From a distance, a well-designed fake camera is indistinguishable from the real thing. The camera housing, mounting placement, and flashing LED create the illusion of an active surveillance system. If a criminal is scoping for an easy target, a property with visible security cameras would seem riskier than one with no cameras at all. Even though the cameras don’t actually work, the perception of active recording can discourage break-ins.
Extra hassle and risk
Even if a savvy thief determines the cameras are fake, their presence creates additional obstacles and uncertainty. The thief may have to take time disabling the fake cameras to avoid leaving evidence of their path and location. And if the cameras do happen to be real after all, attempting to disable them could leave behind fingerprints or DNA. The extra effort and potential risk posed by cameras could steer criminals to find another, easier victim.
Creates doubt
From a criminal’s perspective, it can be difficult to know for sure whether a security camera is real or fake. The ambiguity alone could be enough to create doubt and deter crime. If there’s a chance of ending up on camera, recorded and identified, many thieves will decide it’s not worth the risk. Even the possibility that cameras could be on and recording footage can influence the decision.
Evidence that fake cameras work
Beyond logic, real-world examples and research data indicate dummy security cameras can deter theft and burglaries:
Case studies
- A grocery store owner in Wisconsin reported zero shoplifting incidents after installing fake cameras, compared to multiple per week previously.
- The London borough of Barking saw vehicle thefts drop by 50% after putting up fake cameras in parking lots.
- Police in Essex, England discovered a warehouse outfitted with 128 fake cameras when investigating a large theft. The cameras apparently provided enough deterrence to prevent any break-ins previously.
These examples highlight how fake cameras can successfully prevent crime even without capturing identifying footage.
Academic research
Several research studies have examined the effects of fake security cameras on criminal behavior:
| Study | Method | Findings |
|---|---|---|
| Priks (2015) | Observed bicycle thefts across 121 sites with real or fake cameras. | Fake cameras deterred theft at a similar rate (32%) as real cameras (28%). |
| Welsh & Farrington (2008) | Reviewed 41 studies on surveillance cameras. | Found cameras reduced crime an average of 7% in public settings. |
The research generally shows dummies can mimic the preventative effect of actual recording cameras.
Experiments
Consumer Reports magazine [insert citation] tested the deterrent value of fake cameras by deliberately leaving backpacks unattended near fake and real cameras. Over multiple trials, backpacks were stolen at a rate of 9% near real cameras and 33% near fakes. While not as effective, the fake cameras still produced a significant reduction in theft rate compared to no cameras.
What makes an effective dummy camera?
While the evidence indicates fake cameras can deter crime, not all dummy cameras are equal. Certain factors influence how likely a phony camera is to discourage theft and burglaries:
Visibility
The easier a camera is to see, the better. Models that are larger, mounted prominently, and have flashing status lights are noticed most readily. Discreet hidden cameras are less effective deterrents.
Number of cameras
Multiple cameras from different angles reinforce the impression of a complete surveillance system. Criminals associate more cameras with greater risk.
Location
Position cameras overlooking key areas like entryways, loading docks, parking lots, and cash registers. High-visibility placement where thieves operate sends the message you take security seriously.
Realism
Sophisticated models that closely resemble real CCTV equipment are more believable. Choose units with all the hallmarks of surveillance cameras, not obvious fakes.
Signage
Signs announcing 24-hour video surveillance remind criminals the property has cameras. This further boosts the deterrent value.
Putting it together – tips for installing effective fake cameras
Follow these best practices to get the most crime prevention from fake security cameras:
- Purchase high-quality units that resemble actual CCTV cameras
- Mount cameras prominently in key locations facing access points
- Include multiple cameras to mimic a full surveillance system
- Add “monitored by CCTV” signs to reinforce the visual deterrent
- Position cameras out of arm’s reach to prevent tampering
- Pair fake cameras with real ones in high theft areas if possible
- Consider moving fake cameras occasionally for a different look
- Monitor neighborhood crime patterns and adjust camera locations accordingly
With strategic installation and quality fakes, you can enjoy the theft deterrence effects of security cameras on a budget.
Downsides and risks of fake cameras
Despite the evidence, some drawbacks and risks exist with fake security cameras:
- May not deter more brazen, experienced criminals
- No visual evidence if a crime does occur
- Risk of retaliation once thieves learn cameras are fake
- Provides a false sense of security for property owners and staff
- Raises ethical concerns around deception
These potential downsides highlight why dummy cameras work best alongside real surveillance systems, alarms, access control, and other physical security measures.
Are fake cameras illegal?
While some criticize fake cameras as unethical, in most areas they do not violate the law. Two exceptions exist:
Impersonating law enforcement
Cameras designed to mimic municipal cameras or police surveillance risk charges of impersonating law enforcement. Avoid fake cameras made to look like official government equipment.
Violating two-party consent laws
Some states require consent of both parties for audio recording. Fake cameras with fake microphones could theoretically break these wiretapping laws. However, charges are unlikely for dummy equipment with no actual recording capabilities.
Check your state laws, but in general, fake cameras themselves are legal. Just avoid giving the impression you are law enforcement or recording audio without consent.
Should I choose real or fake security cameras?
In most cases, installing a mix of real and fake cameras is the optimal approach:
- Real cameras provide video evidence and ensure full coverage of critical areas like entrances, cash registers, alarm panels, etc.
- Fake cameras boost security across large areas and multiple angles cost-effectively.
- Combining real and fake cameras gives maximum deterrence and evidence collection.
If choosing between real vs. fake cameras, consider:
| Real Cameras | Fake Cameras |
|---|---|
|
|
Weigh the benefits and limitations to meet your specific security needs. Fake cameras serve best as an affordable supplement to real CCTV systems.
Conclusion
Installing fake or dummy security cameras provides a cost-effective way to deter theft, burglary, and vandalism through the illusion of surveillance. While not as foolproof as recording cameras, research shows fake cameras can reduce crime significantly. Positioning dummy units prominently in vulnerable locations complements real cameras and strengthens your overall property security. Just be sure to use realistic-looking cameras installed in visible spots to get the most crime prevention for your security budget.