Electric plug in pest repellers are devices that are claimed to use sound waves or electromagnetic waves to repel pests like insects, rodents, and other critters from homes and businesses. But do these devices really work? Here is an in-depth look at the technology behind electric pest repellers and an evaluation of their effectiveness.
Page Contents
How do electric plug in pest repellers work?
There are two main types of technology used in electric plug in pest repellers:
- Ultrasonic pest repellers – These devices emit high frequency sound waves that are above the range of human hearing. The ultrasonic waves are unpleasant and disorienting for pests like rodents and insects, driving them away.
- Electromagnetic pest repellers – These devices create electromagnetic fields that interfere with the nervous systems of pests. This makes it uncomfortable for them to remain in the affected area.
Manufacturers of electric pest repellers claim that these technologies create zones around the devices where pests will not want to linger. The effective radius depends on the power output of the device but is often advertised as covering up to 1,200 square feet.
Ultrasonic technology
Ultrasonic pest repellers produce high frequency sound waves, often between 25,000 to 65,000 Hz. This is above the audible hearing range for humans, which tops out at around 20,000 Hz for most adults. However, rodents can hear up to 80,000 Hz and insects have an even higher audible frequency range.
The claim is that when pests are exposed to these ultrasonic frequencies, it creates an unpleasant sensation that they will want to avoid. It may produce effects like:
- Disorientation and confusion
- Pain or irritation
- Interference with communication
This supposedly motivates rodents and insects to leave the area and look for more hospitable surroundings. The effectiveness depends on producing sufficient sound intensity at the right ultrasonic frequencies to elicit negative reactions from the pests.
Electromagnetic technology
Electromagnetic pest repellers work by producing electromagnetic radiation waves. Even small household electrical devices emit some electromagnetic radiation. But pest repellers are designed to generate targeted wavelengths and concentrated fields of electromagnetic energy.
These electromagnetic waves are said to interfere with the nervous systems of pests that venture into the fields being emitted by the devices. Reported effects include:
- Disruption of reproductive capabilities
- Interference with proper food digestion
- Inability to sleep properly
- Disorientation and confusion
- Unpleasant sensations
The claim is that pests will flee these negative effects the same way they would flee from a predator or hazard. Manufacturers assert that electromagnetic pest repellers can provide powerful repelling effects on rodents and insects, driving them away from the treated areas.
Do ultrasonic pest repellers work?
There are conflicting reports about the effectiveness of ultrasonic pest repellers. Some studies and anecdotal reports indicate they do little or nothing to deter pests. However, some studies have found measurable effects, suggesting they may work under certain conditions.
Evidence that ultrasonic repellers don’t work
- Entomologists from universities like Cornell have reported that ultrasonic devices had no observable effects on cockroach behavior in experiments.
- Consumer Reports tested several popular ultrasonic repellers and concluded they did not drive mice away from areas they inhabited.
- The FTC has fined companies like Anderson Laboratories for making unsupported claims about their ultrasonic mole and gopher repellers.
The skepticism about ultrasonic pest repellers is that evolution has already attuned rodents and insects to avoiding high frequency sounds indicative of predators. Producing generic high pitched noises without specific behavioral cues may have little effect.
Evidence supporting ultrasonic repellers
On the other hand, some evidence indicates that ultrasonic pest repellers can work under the right circumstances:
- A study in the Journal of Economic Entomology found that ultrasound caused a statistically significant decrease in silverfish populations compared to control groups.
- Researchers in India reported ultrasonic sound successfully repelled 83% of mosquitos in one test during peak biting times.
- A study in Ultrasonics journal found combining ultrasound, light, and airflow helped repel cockroaches in large indoor areas.
The evidence supporting ultrasonic pest repellers suggests they may have some behavioral effects on rodents and insects, especially in confined spaces. But results appear very dependent on device placement and settings.
Do electromagnetic pest repellers work?
As with ultrasonic repellers, there are conflicting reports on whether electromagnetic pest repellers effectively drive away pests. Some questions remain about their technological capabilities.
Evidence questioning electromagnetic repellers
- Consumer Reports testing found electromagnetic repellers did not drive mice away from favorable areas.
- University of Arizona entomologists reported that electromagnetic devices had no measurable behavioral effects on termites in lab experiments.
- The EPA does not recognize electromagnetic radiation as an effective sole means of pest control.
Critics argue most affordable electromagnetic pest repellers do not generate enough concentrated energy to substantially impact rodents and insects. Home appliances already generate similar ambient radiation.
Evidence supporting electromagnetic repellers
However, there is also some scientific data suggesting electromagnetic pest repellers can work:
- A study in the Journal of Economic Entomology found electromagnetic radiation impacted ant behavior and physiology in lab conditions.
- Czech researchers described favorable results using very specific electromagnetic frequencies to repel flies.
- A 2017 study found EM radiation devices reduced rodent populations on small farms over several weeks.
Proponents argue that more advanced electromagnetic generating devices, rather than simple plug-in repellers, may impact pests by producing targeted radiation. Affordability and energy usage are current barriers.
Key factors impacting effectiveness
Given the mixed evidence, what factors may determine whether ultrasonic and electromagnetic pest repellers are effective or not? Key elements include:
- Device settings – The specific frequencies generated and their intensities appear to make a major difference. Products with manual tuning may fare better than “one setting works on all pests” devices.
- Repeller placement – Positioning repellers correctly based on room dimensions and pest entry points makes them more effective.
- Pest species – Certain rodents and insects may be more susceptible than others to high frequency sounds and EM waves due to their hearing sensitivities.
- Environmental factors – Elements like temperature, humidity, and obstruction by objects impact how the waves spread from repellers.
- Supplemental techniques – Combining repellers with other methods like traps, sanitation, and sealing may improve results.
Used strategically in optimal conditions rather than “set it and forget it” deployment, there is evidence ultrasonic and electromagnetic repellers may provide results. However, inconsistent pest responses remain an issue.
Tips for effective use of electric pest repellers
If you wish to try using electric plug in pest repellers, here are some tips to maximize your chances of success:
- Carefully follow the placement instructions in the product manual to ensure sufficient coverage of affected areas.
- Use multiple units spaced appropriately to create overlapping fields for better area coverage.
- Directly place repellers along pest entry points and common travel paths when possible.
- Combine repellers with other pest management tactics for enhanced results.
- Keep the devices protected from dirt, dust, and moisture to maintain effectiveness.
- Adjust settings over time if initial configuration does not seem to be working.
- Be patient as it may take days or weeks of exposure to drive pests away.
Realistically, at best ultrasonic and electromagnetic repellers should only be part of an integrated pest management plan rather than the sole anti-pest technique.
Alternative pest control options
Electric pest repellers have questionable or context-dependent effectiveness for many homeowners and businesses. Fortunately, there are various alternate pest control options to consider instead:
Chemical pesticides
Pesticides remain one of the quickest and most potent ways to eliminate rodents, insects, and other pests. Formulations like insect sprays, foggers, bait traps, and rodent poison can all provide lethal results when used properly. Always carefully follow safety and application directions.
Physical traps
From old fashioned snap traps to modern live-catch traps, physically capturing rodents and larger insects is a direct way to remove pests from the premises and humanely relocate or dispose of them.
Biological control
Natural predators like snakes, geckos, and birds of prey can eliminate pest populations in a property’s surroundings. Introducing sterilized male insects can also collapse populations. Precision applications of microbial insecticides provide safe biological control indoors.
Sanitation and maintenance
Sealing cracks, clearing clutter, regular cleaning, removing trash, and upgrading storage can remove insect and rodent access to food, water, and nesting sites inside a building. This pest-proofing limits infestation risks.
An integrated pest management (IPM) strategy combining several of these approaches tailored to the specific pest issue generally offers the best results rather than just relying on plug-in repellers alone.
Conclusion
Do electric plug in pest repellers work? The bottom line is results are hit or miss based on the specific products, pests involved, environmental conditions, and proper usage. Ultrasonic and electromagnetic repellers appear incapable of completely eliminating pest populations on their own but may have partial or situational impacts on behavior.
While pest repeller technology continues to evolve, proven methods like sanitation measures, traps, targeted pesticides, and biological control should form the core of any pest management program. Ultrasonic and electromagnetic repellers can serve as supplements but not sole solutions. Carefully monitor their results and adjust strategies as needed to keep pests under control without relying on plug-in devices as magic fixes.