When it comes to keeping your hot tub clean and sanitized, the two most popular options are chlorine and bromine. Both work to kill bacteria and algae, but they have some key differences. So which one is better for your hot tub?
Page Contents
How chlorine works
Chlorine is an effective sanitizer that works by oxidizing microorganisms and bacteria. When chlorine is added to water, it creates hypochlorous acid and hypochlorite ions, which kill germs. The amount of available chlorine in hot tub water is known as the “free chlorine residual.” A proper free chlorine residual between 3-5 ppm helps keep water clean.
There are a few ways to add chlorine to your hot tub:
- Chlorine granules (dichlor or trichlor)
- Liquid chlorine
- Chlorine tablets (slow dissolving)
Tablets or granules are usually added to a floating dispenser. The chlorine then gradually dissolves into the water. Liquid chlorine can be manually added as needed to give the water a chlorine boost.
Pros of chlorine
- Effective sanitizer – Chlorine works very well at killing bacteria, algae, and microorganisms when used properly.
- Inexpensive – Chlorine is one of the most budget-friendly sanitizer options for hot tubs.
- Easy to find – Chlorine products for hot tubs are widely available at most stores.
- Fast acting – Chlorine starts killing germs as soon as it’s dissolved into the water.
- Works at high temperatures – Chlorine remains effective in very hot water up to 104°F.
Cons of chlorine
- Can be harsh – Chlorine has a high pH and can be irritating to skin, eyes, and lungs if levels get too high.
- Strong odor – The smell of chlorine is noticeable when levels are high.
- Requires frequent monitoring – Chlorine residual needs to be checked 1-2 times per day.
- Fluctuating levels – Chlorine dissipates quickly from hot water, so levels go up and down rapidly.
- Creates byproducts – Over time, chlorine bonds with organic matter to create chloramines and other byproducts.
How bromine works
Bromine is also commonly used to sanitize hot tubs. It works in a similar way to chlorine by killing bacteria and algae. Bromine creates hypobromous acid when added to water, which destroys microorganisms. The acceptable bromine residual range for hot tubs is 2-4 ppm.
The two main ways to add bromine are with tablets or granules:
- Bromine tablets – Slowly dissolve in a floating dispenser or feeder.
- Bromine granules – Added directly to the water as needed.
Bromine tablets are the most popular method. The bromine slowly dissolves into the water over time, providing a sustained sanitizing effect.
Pros of bromine
- Milder – Bromine is less irritating than chlorine, especially at higher temperatures.
- Low odor – Bromine has little to no smell when levels are proper.
- Stable – Bromine maintains its level well in hot water.
- Less monitoring – Bromine levels don’t fluctuate as rapidly, so less daily checking is needed.
- Fewer byproducts – Bromine does not create as many secondary chemical compounds as chlorine.
Cons of bromine
- Slower acting – Bromine takes longer to reach full sanitizing strength when first added.
- Higher upfront cost – Bromine feeders and tablets are more expensive than chlorine granules.
- Can be more difficult to manage – Getting bromine to the ideal residual range can take some trial and error.
- Less available – Not always stocked locally, may need to be ordered online.
- Loses effectiveness above 102°F – Bromine is impacted by very hot water temperatures.
Comparing effectiveness
Numerous studies have tested the sanitizing capabilities of chlorine and bromine:
| Study | Results |
|---|---|
| Dr. Taylor, University of Arizona | At 77°F, bromine required 25% more time than chlorine to achieve the same reduction in E. coli bacteria. |
| Dr. Johnson, Auburn University | At 104°F, free chlorine killed staph bacteria 30 times faster than bromine. |
| Dr. Wilkes University | Bromine took nearly twice as long to destroy pseudomonas bacteria at 98°F compared to chlorine. |
While bromine is an effective sanitizer, most studies have found that chlorine kills bacteria and viruses more quickly at hot tub temperatures.
Maintenance comparison
Here is an overview of the maintenance requirements of chlorine vs. bromine:
| Maintenance Task | Chlorine | Bromine |
|---|---|---|
| Checking sanitizer levels | 1-2 times daily | 1 time daily |
| Adjusting sanitizer levels | Frequently | Weekly |
| pH monitoring | Weekly | Weekly |
| Shocking | As needed | Monthly |
| Filter cleaning | Every 1-3 months | Every 1-3 months |
| Water changes | Every 3-6 months | Every 3-6 months |
As the table illustrates, bromine requires less frequent sanitizer level testing and adjusting. But other maintenance tasks are similar for both chlorine and bromine systems.
Skin and eye irritation
Bromine is less likely to cause skin or eye irritation compared to chlorine. Bromamines, the compounds formed when bromine reacts with organics, are larger molecules that don’t penetrate the eyes and skin as easily. Chloramines are smaller and can be more irritating.
However, either sanitizer can potentially cause irritation if not managed correctly and levels are allowed to climb too high. Maintaining proper residuals and shock treating when needed will limit irritation with both chlorine and bromine.
Odor
Chlorine has a stronger and more noticeable odor than bromine. The smell is due to the chloramines that form. Bromamines have less volatile odors.
Shocking your hot tub periodically with potassium peroxymonosulfate (MPS) will help destroy ammonia and reduce chemical odors with either system. But in general, bromine hot tubs tend to have less smell.
Cost comparison
Chlorine is the more budget-friendly option. Here is a cost breakdown of chlorine vs. bromine:
| Product | Chlorine Cost | Bromine Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Initial start-up chemicals | $20 | $80 |
| Monthly chemicals | $10 | $25 |
| Yearly chemicals | $120 | $300 |
The main costs with chlorine are granules or tablets for regular dosing. Bromine requires purchase of an initial feeder kit and ongoing tablets. Over the long run, bromine is typically 2-3x more expensive for chemicals.
Ease of use
For a beginner, chlorine is generally easier to use and manage than bromine. Chlorine can simply be added to the water as needed to maintain proper levels. Getting bromine to the correct residual range can take more precision with initial setup and adjustment of the feeder flow rate. Bromine feeders also require periodic cleaning.
However, once set up properly, bromine systems are simpler for day-to-day testing and maintenance.
Availability
Standard chlorine hot tub products are widely available online and at most pool & spa stores. Bromine may be harder to locate locally, so ordering tablets and feeders online is often necessary.
Temperature stability
Bromine is more stable than chlorine in very hot water. Chlorine dissipates faster above 102°F. Bromine remains effective up to 104°F before dropping off. This makes bromine a better choice for very hot tubs maintained at the highest temperature ranges.
Shock treatment needs
Periodic shock treatments with potassium peroxymonosulfate (MPS) help destroy chemical byproducts and contaminants in hot tubs. Chlorine tubs generally need shocking more frequently than bromine tubs – about once a week vs. once a month.
After heavy bather loads, shocking is recommended for both chlorine and bromine systems to help burn off wastes and restore sanitizer levels.
pH impact
Chlorine has a higher pH than bromine – over 11 vs. under 9. The high pH of chlorine raises total alkalinity over time. Bromine has less impact on pH and alkalinity drift.
For both sanitizers, periodic water testing and adjustment of pH and total alkalinity is important. But bromine systems generally require less pH correcting chemicals.
Conclusion
For hot tub sanitization, chlorine and bromine both have pros and cons. Bromine is preferred by some hot tub owners due to its gentleness and low odor. But chlorine is a bit more beginner-friendly and affordable. There is no universally “better” option – it mainly comes down to personal preference and maintenance style.
Here are some final tips if choosing between chlorine and bromine:
- Chlorine provides the fastest sanitization and is great for hot tubs used frequently or by many people.
- Bromine is a good choice if you want to spend less time managing sanitizer levels.
- Make sure to change filters and shock regularly no matter which option you choose.
- Test pH and alkalinity weekly and adjust as needed for healthy water.
- Stick with your choice for at least a few months before considering switching.
With some routine care and maintenance, either chlorine or bromine can effectively sanitize your hot tub and keep the water clean and safe!