Flood lights are a common type of outdoor lighting used to illuminate large areas such as sports fields, construction sites, or parking lots. While flood lights are an effective lighting solution in many situations, there are some downsides to consider. The high-intensity light can create glare and light pollution. Flood lights also consume a large amount of electricity. For these reasons, many homeowners and businesses are looking for alternative lighting solutions.
Page Contents
What are the downsides of flood lights?
Here are some of the main disadvantages of flood lights:
- Glare – The bright, direct light from flood lights can cause glare, which is irritating and can make it difficult to see clearly in the illuminated area.
- Light pollution – Flood lights shine light sideways and upwards, contributing to artificial skyglow around cities. This disrupts ecosystems and obscures views of the night sky.
- Electricity consumption – Flood lights require high wattage bulbs and use a significant amount of electricity, leading to high energy bills.
- Heat production – The bright bulbs also generate a lot of heat, impacting cooling costs in warm weather.
- Light trespass – Bright flood lights often spill over property lines, causing nuisance light for neighbors.
Many homeowners associations and municipalities have regulations limiting flood light use for these reasons. Overall, flood lights can create glare, waste energy, impact the environment, and disturb neighbors when improperly installed or overused.
What alternatives work well?
Here are some of the best options to consider instead of flood lights:
LED security lights
LED security lights are a direct replacement for traditional flood lights. They use LED bulbs which consume much less energy and last longer than the incandescent or halogen bulbs used in flood lights. LED security lights come in a wide range of styles such as:
- Wall-mounted LED lights
- Pole-mounted LED lights
- Solar-powered LED motion lights
They provide bright, focused illumination while avoiding the excessive glare and light trespass of flood lights. Most LED security lights include motion sensors so the light only turns on when needed.
Path lighting
Path lighting uses small, low-voltage fixtures to illuminate walking paths and driveways. Shorter light posts ranging from knee height to head height line the path, providing localized pools of light without excessive glare or light pollution. Options include:
- Bollard lights – Freestanding, short light posts.
- Step lights – Small fixtures built into walls, steps, or curbs.
- Deck lights – Low-voltage lights built into or mounted on deck railings.
Path lighting improves visibility and safety without harsh glare. The smaller fixtures also use less energy compared to flood lights. Path lighting works well to illuminate walking paths in yards, driveways, parking areas, and outdoor stairs.
Accent lighting
Accent lighting refers to directional lighting fixtures aimed at architectural features, landscaping, or trees. For example:
- Up lighting – Lights directed up at building walls to highlight architectural details.
- Down lighting – Lights mounted in eaves or structures and aimed down at the ground.
- Silhouette lighting – Backlighting of trees and landscaping to create a silhouette.
Accent lighting provides dramatic effects with focused beams of light. LED fixtures consume relatively little energy but have high visual impact. Accent lighting enhances safety by improving spatial awareness and visibility without unnecessary glare.
In-ground lighting
In-ground lighting refers to fixtures installed flush with the ground. Options include:
- Landscape lighting – Lights installed at the base of trees or aimed at other landscaping.
- Hardscape lighting – Linear lighting installed around driveways, paths, pools, or steps.
In-ground lighting is extremely low profile but can achieve landscape illumination similar to flood lights with less glare. The ground-level fixtures also produce very minimal light trespass to neighboring properties.
Smart lighting
Smart lighting systems include automated controls to manage outdoor lighting more efficiently. Features include:
- Motion sensors – Lights turn on only when motion is detected and turn off after a delay when activity ceases.
- Photocells – Natural light sensors that keep lights off during the day.
- Smart scheduling – Automated on/off schedules matched to homeowners’ routines.
- Dimming – Brightness adjusts automatically based on conditions.
Smart lighting minimizes light pollution and electricity consumption from outdoor lighting while maintaining flexibility, automation, and custom control.
What are the best flood light alternatives for home security?
The key is choosing alternatives that provide better visibility and safety without excessive light. Here are some of the best options:
LED security lights
LED security lights are the most direct replacement option for flood lights on homes. The LED versions provide bright, uniform light for monitoring driveways, backyards, and entrances just like traditional flood lights. However, they create less glare and light trespass. Features like motion sensors provide automatic security lighting when needed.
Path lighting
Path lighting along driveways, walks, stairs, and decks improves visibility at night for arriving home while avoiding glare issues. Strategically placed path lighting guides visitors while deterring intruders.
Accent lighting
Subtle uplighting or downlighting on landscaping, walls, and architectural features improves spatial awareness and visibility around the home for security purposes.
In-ground lighting
In-ground lighting around the property perimeter provides low-profile illumination. Linear lighting along driveways or pathways subtly guides visitors to proper entrances.
Smart lighting
Automated smart security lighting only turns on when needed and adjusts brightness based on motion and daylight conditions. This provides optimal light for safety when required while avoiding energy waste and nuisance lighting.
What are the best alternatives for glare-free lighting?
Glare control is essential for outdoor lighting applications. Here are some of the best options for glare-free illumination:
Full cut-off fixtures
Full cut-off fixtures allow no light emission above a horizontal plane through the light source. This controls glare by preventing upward light trespass. Cut-off fixtures should be used for wall mounts, pole/post-top lights, and bollards.
Louvred or shielded fixtures
Louvres, baffles, and shields significantly limit side glare. The light shines down with minimal horizontal light trespass to cause glare issues.
Path lighting
Path lighting fixtures are close to the ground, directed down, and spaced appropriately to eliminate glare. The small scale lighting eliminates intense hot spots of light.
Accent lighting
Properly angled accent lighting focuses light tightly on architectural and landscaping elements. This controlled beam minimizes glare or spill light in surrounding areas.
In-ground lighting
Light emanating from in-ground fixtures has minimal opportunity to cause glare due to very low angle relative to viewers. Light is directed and diffused gently rather than shining horizontally.
Indirect lighting
Indirect lighting bounces light off surfaces to illuminate while hiding the light source. This diffuses glare from the fixture itself.
What are the most cost-effective outdoor lighting alternatives?
Cost analysis of outdoor lighting options should consider upfront costs, energy use, and maintenance requirements. Here are some of the most cost-effective choices:
LED technology
LEDs are the most energy efficient bulbs for outdoor lighting. Though LED fixtures have a higher upfront cost, they use a fraction of the energy of incandescent or halogen lighting and last much longer.
Solar-powered lighting
Solar-powered path, security, and accent lights have no wiring or electricity costs. Though solar fixtures have higher upfront costs, energy savings from the sun can provide a fast payback.
Motion sensors
Adding motion sensors to control any type of outdoor lighting allows the fixtures to remain off when not needed. This saves a tremendous amount of energy.
Timers and automated controls
Like motion sensors, automated controls allow outdoor lighting to be selectively turned on or dimmed. Smart controls prevent energy waste from lights remaining on longer than needed.
Multi-level and dimmable lighting
Dimmable fixtures or lighting designs with adjustable multi-level brightness settings allow light levels to be tuned precisely for each use instead of wasting excessive illumination.
Path lighting
Path lighting consumes very little energy due to low voltage and small fixture size. Extensive lighting is possible within reasonable energy budgets.
Accent lighting
LED accent lighting also consumes minimal energy for the dramatic effects created. Careful accent lighting can provide extensive lighting from just a few small fixtures.
Conclusion
Flood lights are prone to issues with glare, light pollution, energy waste, and light trespass. Property owners have an increasing number of better alternatives for effective and efficient outdoor lighting design.
Modern lighting technology like LEDs and smart lighting systems paired with design techniques such as path lighting, accent lighting, and in-ground fixtures allow strategic illumination with minimal glare and light pollution issues. These alternatives also offer much better energy efficiency compared to using flood lights.
By moving away from excessive flood lighting, homeowners and businesses can enjoy better visibility, safety, and security while also preventing nuisance lighting on neighboring properties and reducing electricity consumption.