What is the best way to attach deck boards?

When building or replacing a deck, one of the most important decisions is how to properly attach the deck boards. Proper attachment is crucial for structural integrity, safety, and longevity of the deck. There are a few main methods for attaching deck boards, each with their own pros and cons.

Deck Board Attachment Methods

The three main methods for attaching deck boards are:

  • Face screwing
  • Hidden fasteners
  • Ledger boards

Face Screwing

Face screwing involves driving screws directly through the face (top) of the deck boards and into the joists below. This is the most common and straightforward method. It simply requires drilling pilot holes in the exact location you want the screws, and driving the screws in.

Pros:

  • Very simple and fast to install
  • Provides firm attachment directly to joists
  • Low cost (just need screws and driver)

Cons:

  • Screws are visible on deck surface
  • Can loosen over time as wood shrinks and expands
  • Harder to remove/replace individual boards

Hidden Fasteners

Hidden fasteners are specialty deck screw and clip systems that allow you to attach boards without any visible screws or nails. They clip into grooves on the sides of deck boards and fasten into the joists.

Pros:

  • Creates smooth, screwless deck surface
  • Allows for some wood movement
  • Easier to replace individual boards

Cons:

  • More expensive than face screwing
  • Can loosen over time if not installed correctly
  • Grooved deck boards may cost more

Ledger Boards

With the ledger board method, a second board is attached horizontally to the rim joist, creating a small ledger for the ends of the deck boards to rest on. The deck boards are toenailed or screwed into the ledger board.

Pros:

  • No visible screws on deck surface
  • Allows for some wood movement
  • Provides very firm attachment

Cons:

  • More labor intensive to install ledger
  • Deck board ends still visible
  • Replacing boards can be challenging

Best Practices for Attaching Deck Boards

When selecting a deck board attachment method, consider factors like budget, appearance, maintenance, and accessibility. Here are some best practices to ensure proper installation:

  • Use screws or nails rated for treated lumber
  • Allow 1/4″ gaps between boards for drainage and expansion
  • Attach boards at appropriate intervals based on board width
  • Drill pilot holes to prevent wood splitting
  • Follow manufacturer’s instructions for any hidden fastener system
  • Stagger boards randomly, don’t line up seams

Recommended Attachment Methods by Deck Board Type

The best attachment method can also depend on the specific type of deck boards you select. Here are some recommended methods:

Deck Board Material Best Attachment Method
Pressure-Treated Pine Face screwing or ledger board
Cedar Hidden fasteners
Composite Hidden fasteners
Ipe Face screwing
Bamboo Hidden fasteners

Conclusion

When installing deck boards, taking the time to properly attach them is a crucial step. Face screwing, hidden fasteners, and ledger boards all have their pros and cons. Consider factors like decking material, appearance, budget, and ease of maintenance and replacement. With proper attachment and spacing, your deck boards will have maximum strength and longevity.