When working with concrete, having the right tools for the job is crucial to achieving high quality results. One of the most important tools is the driver, which is used to drive nails, screws and other fasteners into concrete. With so many driver types available, choosing the best one for your needs can be challenging. In this article, we’ll compare the most common driver types for concrete applications and discuss the pros and cons of each to help you select the right one.
Page Contents
Impact Driver
An impact driver is powered by compressed air or batteries and delivers a rotational striking motion to drive fasteners into dense materials like concrete. Here are some key features and considerations when using an impact driver for concrete:
Pros
– Generates a high level of torque and power in a compact size, allowing you to drive large fasteners with ease. Most impact drivers provide 1,200 to 1,500 inch-pounds of torque.
– The hammering action prevents the bit from slipping out of the screw head and damaging the material surface.
– Variable speed triggers give you control over the power and speed.
– Cordless battery-powered models provide portability and convenience without dealing with air hoses.
Cons
– Not designed for precision work. The hammering makes it difficult to control the depth and angle.
– Loud hammering noise. You’ll need hearing protection when working for extended periods.
– Higher cost than drill/drivers. Mainly intended for heavy fastening tasks rather than occasional jobs.
Rotary Hammer
Rotary hammers combine a hammering mechanism with rotary capability, making them ideal for drilling into concrete as well as driving fasteners. Here are the main benefits and downsides:
Pros
– Generates the highest impact energy and blows per minute compared to other driver types, making them ideal for drilling large holes in concrete and masonry.
– Active vibration control technologies minimize vibrations for greater comfort and control.
– Can also be used for light chiseling work. SDS max chucks accept a wide variety of bit types.
– Variety of barrel sizes available from compact to heavy-duty. Larger sizes generate higher torque for more driving power.
Cons
– Heavier and bulkier than other driver options. Not practical for overhead use or tight spaces.
– Power and performance comes at a steep price. Rotary hammers cost significantly more than impact drivers.
– Overkill for basic driving tasks. Better suited to frequent heavy-duty drilling and driving.
Hammer Drill
Hammer drills provide a combination of hammering action and regular drilling capabilities. Here are the main upsides and downsides when using one for concrete applications:
Pros
– Lower cost option compared to rotary hammers and impact drivers. Ideal for occasional concrete drilling/driving tasks.
– Compact and lightweight design improves maneuverability in tight spots. Easier to use overhead.
– Variable speed settings and adjustable hammering function allows better control over impact energy.
– Can also be used for regular drilling in wood and metal. More versatile than specialized drivers.
Cons
– Lower torque and hammering power than impact drivers and rotary hammers. Not suitable for heavy duty tasks.
– Hammering action is not as optimized for driving tasks as in an impact driver. Higher risk of bit slippage.
– Generally only accept hex-shank bits rather than SDS chucks. Less bit versatility.
Drill/Driver
Standard drill/drivers that don’t have a hammer function can still be used for occasional concrete drilling and driving with the right bits. Here are the main pros and cons:
Pros
– Extremely versatile for a wide range of drilling and driving applications in various materials. A good all-purpose tool.
– Very compact and lightweight. Easier to use in tight spaces and overhead.
– Lower pricing than specialized driver tools. A good choice for DIYers or basic tasks.
Cons
– Lack the hammering action needed for efficient concrete drilling/driving. Harder on the tool and operator.
– Higher risk of bit slipping, damaging the surface, or snapping under torque. Not optimal for heavy loads.
– Slow process compared to proper hammering drivers. Requires applying more pressure.
Key Considerations
When selecting the best concrete driver for your needs, keep these key tips in mind:
– Consider how often you’ll be working with concrete. Occasional users can get by with a standard drill/driver or hammer drill, while frequent concrete work justifies an impact driver or rotary hammer.
– Hammer drills are a good compromise offering moderate concrete drilling/driving ability along with versatility for other materials. They’re a reasonable choice for DIYers.
– Match the driver’s power and impact energy level to the demands of the job. Larger tasks require higher torque, BPM, and barrel size.
– Opt for SDS chucks over standard hex-shanks for greater bit versatility in rotary hammers and hammer drills.
– Cordless battery drivers provide greatest portability and convenience. Larger batteries offer longer runtimes.
– Always use bits specifically designed for concrete drilling and driving. Carbide tips and optimized geometries prevent wear and breakage.
– Wear eye and ear protection when using power drivers. Vibration reducing gloves also help improve comfort and control.
Driver Comparison Table
To visualize the key differences between driver types, here is a comparison table:
| Driver Type | Power Source | Hammering Action | Torque | Drilling Ability | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Impact Driver | Air, Battery | Yes | High | No | $$$$ |
| Rotary Hammer | Corded Electric | Yes | Highest | Yes | $$$$$ |
| Hammer Drill | Corded/Cordless | Yes | Moderate | With Special Bits | $$$ |
| Drill/Driver | Corded/Cordless | No | Low-Moderate | No | $ |
Conclusion
When driving fasteners into concrete, an impact driver or rotary hammer are the optimal choices to make the job faster and easier. Their specialized hammering mechanisms deliver much greater speed than regular drill/drivers. For larger tasks demanding high torque and frequent use, rotary hammers are the best pick. But impact drivers deliver an excellent balance of power, precision and portability for most general concrete driving work. Their lower cost makes them accessible for DIYers as well. Hammer drills also deserve consideration for their versatility and moderate concrete ability. Whichever model you choose, always use it with the proper bit designs and safety gear to get the best results. With the right driver for your needs, you’ll be equipped to take on any concrete driving job successfully.