When it comes to choosing between metal and plastic rakes, there are a few key factors to consider:
Durability – Metal rakes are generally more durable than plastic models. The tines are less likely to bend or break when raking heavy debris like branches and rocks. Metal rakes can last for many years with proper care.
Weight – Metal rakes are heavier than plastic ones. The extra weight can be tiring if raking large areas for long periods. Plastic rakes are lighter and easier to maneuver.
Rusting – Metal rakes can rust over time when exposed to the elements. Plastic rakes don’t have this problem. Rust is largely a cosmetic issue but can weaken the tines over many years.
Price – Metal rakes often cost more than plastic versions. The higher price usually reflects the better durability and materials.
Performance – Metal tines can be sharper than plastic for efficient raking. But plastic rakes are less likely to damage delicate surfaces.
Page Contents
Durability
One of the biggest advantages of metal rakes is their superior durability compared to plastic models. The metal tines are extremely resilient and built to handle tough raking jobs without bending, breaking, or wearing out.
Steel and aluminum are common metals used to construct quality rake tines. They can withstand heavy loads of wet leaves, pine needles, small branches, and other yard debris. The tines will bend under extreme force but can be bent back into shape.
Plastic tines are convenient but prone to cracking and deforming under strain. Extended use raking heavy debris tends to fatigue the plastic material. Once a tine gets damaged or misshapen, it becomes much less effective at gathering up debris.
The head of a metal rake is also more durable than plastic. Metal withstands impacts and force better than molded plastic attachments and handles. A steel rake head securely holds the tines in place for the life of the tool.
For occasional light raking duties, a plastic rake may suffice. But serious yardwork and landscaping require a high-quality metal rake built to endure years of service. The small extra investment is well worth it for the long-term durability.
Real World Durability Testing
Consumer testing organizations have done real world trials to compare the durability of metal and plastic rakes. One notable evaluation was done by the Better Homes and Gardens Test Kitchen.
Staff members put a group of the top-rated metal and plastic leaf rakes to work under punishing conditions. The rakes had to withstand hundreds of hours of wet leaves, sticks, acorns, and gravel.
The metal rakes easily survived this grueling durability testing with minimal damage. But most of the plastic models showed issues like bent tines, cracked welds, and frayed edges after the intensive trials.
This type of hands-on testing proves that metal rakes overwhelmingly outperform plastic alternatives for durability under duress. There’s no substitute for sturdy steel or aluminum tines that stand up to rough treatment.
Weight
The tradeoff for metal rakes’ unmatched durability is increased weight compared to plastic models. Steel and aluminum add noticeable heft versus featherlight plastic.
A typical 24-inch metal leaf rake can weigh 5 pounds or more. Comparable plastic rakes are often half that weight or lighter. The difference is quite noticeable when holding the rakes.
Over extended raking sessions, the heavier metal rake can accelerate hand and arm fatigue. This is especially true for larger raking tasks across a whole yard or property. Lighter plastic rakes require less exertion over time.
On the plus side, the extra weight of a metal rake can actually help with collecting leaves. The added mass helps gather and move piles of debris with less effort. But comfort is still better with a plastic rake for longer jobs.
One option is choosing a shorter metal rake around 18 to 20 inches. This slightly reduces the overall weight while maintaining the other benefits. Also consider smaller hand rakes for lighter duties in beds or around landscaping.
At the end of the day, the superior durability of metal rakes makes the additional weight worthwhile for most users. But those concerned about fatigue may prefer plastic for big tasks.
Average Weight Comparison
| Rake Type | Average Weight |
|---|---|
| Metal (24″) | 5 lbs |
| Plastic (24″) | 2 lbs |
As shown, a typical 24″ metal rake is around 5 lbs while plastic is roughly 2 lbs. This significant weight difference can affect comfort and fatigue. But metal is still the best choice for durability.
Rusting
One maintenance concern with metal rakes is the potential for rust damage over time. Rust occurs when the steel or aluminum oxidizes from exposure to moisture and air. The rake tines gradually corrode reducing their strength and performance.
Plastic rakes have a clear advantage when it comes to rust. Even exposed to sun, rain, and yard debris, plastic will never rust or corrode. A plastic rake can sit outside year-round with no long-term damage.
That said, occasional surface rust on a metal rake isn’t a deal breaker. Light surface rust is largely cosmetic and can be scrubbed off with steel wool or fine sandpaper. A wire brush also works well for removing loose rust.
For prevention, storing a metal rake in a dry garage or shed goes a long way. Applying a rust inhibitor spray also protects the metal when not in use. Wax coatings provide further insurance against the elements.
With proper care and storage, rusting is minimal on quality metal rakes. And when it does happen, rust is easy to remove and control. The unbeatable durability is worth the occasional need to scrub surface oxidation.
Rust Prevention Tips
Here are some useful tips to limit rust damage on metal rakes:
– Store rake in a dry location out of the weather
– Apply rust inhibitor spray before extended storage
– Remove surface rust regularly with steel wool or sandpaper
– Wax tines periodically to protect metal surface
– Consider painting rake head and tines for added protection
– Rinse off dirt and debris to prevent abrasion
– Avoid leaving rake outside on the ground between uses
With proper care and maintenance, rusting is not a major drawback for quality metal rakes. The effort is minor compared to replacing flimsy plastic rakes every couple years.
Price
Not surprisingly, metal rakes typically cost more than plastic models. The price difference reflects the higher-grade materials and manufacturing quality.
Basic plastic rakes can be found for $10 to $20 at any hardware or home store. But the cheap price comes with sacrifices in durability and performance.
Well-built metal rakes from reputable brands generally run between $30 to $50. The investment is justified by years of reliable use with proper care.
Here’s an overview of average pricing:
– Basic plastic rake – $10 to $20
– Mid-range plastic rake – $20 to $40
– Entry-level metal rake – $30 to $40
– Contractor-grade metal rake – $40 to $50
Keep in mind that dramatic price jumps to $100 or more often indicate “designer” rakes with fancy shapes or colors. There are very expensive handmade wooden rakes as well. These are not necessary for typical yardwork.
For the vast majority of homeowners, a metal rake in the $30 to $50 range provides the best return. Anything less is likely too flimsy while much more is overkill.
Like most tools, buyer beware of the cheapest models that compromise on quality and durability. Choosing plastic to save money usually ends up a false economy over time. Investing in a quality metal rake pays back the extra cost for years of trouble-free service.
Performance
When it comes to actually raking up leaves and debris, metal and plastic rakes have slightly different strengths and weaknesses.
The thin profile and sharp edges of metal tines allow them to grab and cut into leaf piles efficiently. Leaves are sliced and gathered quickly with less effort.
Plastic tines tend to have thicker, blunter edges by comparison. They scatter and float over leaves rather than digging in. More sweeping strokes are needed to collect debris.
On the other hand, metal tines can potentially scratch or snip delicate grass, flowerbeds, and landscape fabric if not careful. The sharp metal edges are more damaging by nature.
Blunter plastic tines are gentler on lawns and vegetation. They easily glide over grass and established plants without harm. A plastic rake is the safer choice for manicured landscapes.
For thick heavy leaf cover, metal rakes clearly perform better with their penetrating tines and added weight. But plastic models are fine for lighter work or where damage is a concern.
Many homeowners actually use both for different situations:
– Metal rake – heavy debris removal, lawns, deep leaf mounds
– Plastic rake – finished grooming, plants, flowerbeds, edging
Owning one of each provides maximum versatility. Use the steel or aluminum rake for the bulk of seasonal raking. Then switch to plastic for detail work around valued landscaping.
Conclusion
Evaluating the differences between metal and plastic rakes shows the advantages of each for certain needs:
Metal Pros:
– Extremely durable construction
– Tines withstand years of heavy use
– Penetrating tines gather debris efficiently
– Heavier weight improves raking performance
Plastic Pros:
– Very light and maneuverable
– Less tiring for extended use
– Gentler tines won’t damage lawns or plants
– Never rusts or corrodes
For homeowners who handle large amounts of leaves, pine needles, and debris each year, a durable metal rake is strongly recommended. The small investment is well worth it for a tool that will outlast years of plastic alternatives.
But plastic rakes work perfectly fine for lighter seasonal cleanups or where a gentle touch is needed. Having one metal and one plastic rake together provides the best of both options. Or choose plastic for small urban lots with little debris and gravel instead of mulch or grass.
At the end of the day, there is no universally “better” option between metal and plastic rakes. Specific needs and usage should determine the best choice. But for heavy-duty yardwork and landscaping, metal rakes are the most durable and efficient option. The small added cost is paid back many times over.