Are toilet handles easy to replace?

Replacing a toilet handle is a relatively straightforward home improvement project that most DIYers can tackle. The handles control the flushing mechanism and over time can become loose or break entirely. Knowing how to remove and install a new toilet handle can save you the cost of a plumber. In most cases, replacing a toilet handle takes less than 30 minutes.

Reasons to Replace a Toilet Handle

There are several reasons you may need to replace your toilet handle:

• The handle is loose or wiggly. This indicates worn out interior parts or loose connections.
• The handle no longer fully engages the flushing mechanism. A loose or damaged lift chain is often the culprit.
• The handle is cracked or broken. Over time, plastic handles can become brittle and break under pressure.
• You want to update or change the style. Replacing toilet handles is an easy way to update the look of your bathroom.
• It’s leaking. A faulty seal between the handle and tank can cause water to leak out around the handle.

If you notice any of these issues, it’s a sign that the toilet handle needs to be replaced. Catching small problems early can prevent more expensive repairs down the road.

Supplies Needed

Replacing a toilet handle requires just a few simple supplies:

• New toilet handle kit. Make sure to get the correct shape and size for your toilet model.
• Adjustable wrench
• Rag or small bucket
• Replacement lift chain (if needed)

Toilet handle kits are widely available at home improvement stores and online for under $10. The kit will include the new handle and any necessary plastic or metal fasteners. Before starting, inspect the existing handle and note the shape and size. This will help you select the proper replacement.

Turning Off the Water Supply

Before removing the toilet tank lid to replace the handle, you need to shut off the water supply. There is a supply line that runs from the wall to the bottom of the toilet tank. To shut off the water:

1. Locate the water supply valve. It’s typically found on the wall behind the toilet.
2. Turn the valve clockwise until it stops. This cuts off water flow to the toilet.

You may want to flush the toilet one time after shutting off the valve to empty out the tank. Have a rag or small bucket ready to catch any remaining water in the tank.

Removing the Old Toilet Handle

With the water supply off, you can now work on removing the old toilet handle:

1. Take the toilet tank lid off and set it aside.
2. Remove the nut holding the handle to the tank lever. An adjustable wrench works best.
3. Lift off the old handle and set it aside.
4. Detach the lift chain from the flapper. You may need to pry it loose or loosen a nut.

Inspect the exposed tank lever and flapper chain. If either is damaged or worn out, add the necessary replacement parts to your supplies. If the lift chain is reusable, just reconnect it to the new handle later on.

Installing the New Toilet Handle

With the old handle removed, you can install the new replacement handle:

1. Place the new handle onto the tank lever.
2. Secure it in place with the mounting nut. Tighten with your adjustable wrench.
3. reconnect lift chain to handle and flapper.
4. Make any necessary adjustments so the chain has about 1/4 inch of slack.
5. Test flush the toilet a few times to ensure proper operation.

When reconnecting the lift chain, make sure there is just a bit of slack. If the chain is too tight or loose, the flapper won’t seat properly and the toilet may not flush correctly.

Turning the Water Back On

Once you’ve verified that the new toilet handle is working correctly, you can turn the water supply back on:

1. Turn the water supply valve counter-clockwise to restore water flow.
2. Check for any leaks at the valve or tank connections.
3. Allow the tank to fill completely and flush a few more times.

If there are no leaks, you’ve successfully replaced the toilet handle! Be sure to put the tank lid back on tightly. Consider giving the entire toilet a thorough cleaning while you have the tank exposed.

Troubleshooting Common Problems

While most toilet handle replacements go smoothly, issues can come up. Here are some potential problems and solutions:

Problem	Possible Cause	Solution
Toilet won’t flush properly	Chain too loose or too tight	Adjust chain slack
Handle feels loose	Mounting nut needs tightening	Tighten nut securely
Water leaks from handle	Gasket worn out	Ensure gasket is in place
Toilet runs constantly	Flapper not sealing fully	Inspect flapper, clean or replace

When to Call a Plumber

While do-it-yourself toilet handle replacement is straightforward, there are times to call in a professional:

• The toilet tank or bowl is severely cracked or damaged
• The handle mounting bolts are corroded or won’t budge
• You can’t isolate the water supply valve
• Leakage worsens despite new handle

If you encounter major damage to the toilet or complications accessing the internal parts, it’s best to call a plumber. They have specialized tools and skills. They can also determine if toilet replacement is required.

Cost to Replace a Toilet Handle

One of the biggest benefits of DIY toilet handle replacement is cost savings. Hiring a plumber typically costs $150 or more. The DIY cost is under $20 in most cases:

Supply	Estimated Cost
Toilet handle kit	$5 – $15
Toilet lift chain	$3 – $7
Adjustable wrench	$10 – $15
Total DIY Cost	$20 or less

As you can see, you can replace a toilet handle yourself using basic tools and new parts for around $20, saving significantly over hiring a plumber. The small upfront investment will pay off over the lifetime of your toilet.

Conclusion

Replacing a worn out or broken toilet handle is a straightforward DIY bathroom repair. With a few simple tools and supplies, you can swap out an old, faulty toilet handle for a shiny new one in under 30 minutes. The process involves turning off the water, removing the old handle, installing the new one, and reattaching any necessary lift chains and levers. Pay attention to proper lift chain slack. Look for leaks and test flush several times. Common issues like poor flushing and leaks can be addressed with adjustments. Overall, toilet handle replacement is inexpensive and will extend the life of your toilet. Tackle the project yourself and save the cost of a plumber.