If you’re considering replacing your gas fireplace with an electric fireplace, there are a few key factors to consider first. While an electric fireplace can provide similar ambiance and heat to a gas fireplace, there are some notable differences between the two that may impact the feasibility and cost of switching.
Page Contents
Key Differences Between Gas and Electric Fireplaces
Here are some of the main differences between gas and electric fireplaces:
- Fuel source – Gas fireplaces run on natural gas or propane. Electric fireplaces run on electricity and can be plugged into a standard wall outlet.
- Heat output – Gas fireplaces tend to provide more intense heat. Electric fireplaces offer supplemental zone heating.
- Installation and maintenance – Gas fireplaces require professional installation, venting, and periodic inspections/cleaning. Electric fireplaces can be installed by homeowners and have little maintenance.
- Cost to operate – Gas fireplaces require paying for fuel, while electric fireplaces use standard electricity. Operating costs vary based on energy rates.
- Ambiance – Gas fireplaces feature realistic flames. Electric fireplaces may have simulated flames via LED lights or flame effects.
These factors will all impact whether switching from a gas to electric fireplace makes sense for your needs and budget.
Steps to Replace a Gas Fireplace
If you do decide to replace your gas fireplace with an electric model, here is an overview of the process:
- Turn off gas supply and cap gas line – Have a professional shut off and disconnect the gas line that runs to the existing fireplace. They should place a cap on the line.
- Remove old gas fireplace – Carefully extract the old gas fireplace and surrounding decorative material like mantels or stonework. Consult installation manuals as needed.
- Prepare new electric fireplace – Follow included directions to assemble the new electric fireplace. Make any adjustments to accommodate the existing fireplace space.
- Install electric fireplace – Place the new electric fireplace into the prepared space. Make sure it is secure and level.
- Connect electric – Safely run wiring from an outlet to the electric fireplace and connect following instructions. Use proper protective casing for exposed wires.
- Reinstall decorative elements – Mantels, hearths, stonework, etc can be reinstalled around the new fireplace if desired.
- Test operation – Turn on the electric fireplace to ensure it is operating and heating properly before completing the project.
This outlines the basic steps, but always consult the product manuals and have professional assistance for key steps like removing the gas fireplace, capping the gas line, running electrical, and modifying structural elements of the home if needed.
Considerations When Switching Fireplace Types
If you’re weighing whether to switch from a gas to electric fireplace, here are some important considerations:
Installation Requirements
Converting to an electric fireplace requires having adequate electric service and outlets in place. Installation may involve some rewiring or adding circuits to support the electric fireplace’s power demands. Improper electrical connections can cause fires or electrocution risks.
Heating Capacity
Electric fireplaces produce less intense heat than gas models. Smaller electric fireplaces provide supplemental zone heating for spaces up to 400 square feet. Make sure to choose an appropriately sized electric fireplace and have realistic heat expectations.
Operating Costs
Electricity rates in your area will determine the operating cost of an electric fireplace. Gas fireplace fuel prices can fluctuate based on natural gas or propane market prices. Calculate expected electric versus gas costs to decide which offers more affordable long-term operation.
Existing Venting Requirements
Gas fireplaces require venting infrastructure to safely exhaust emissions and fumes. Removing a gas fireplace means the existing venting is no longer needed. Venting removal requires special considerations like sealing off chimneys or external vents.
Aesthetics
Gas fireplaces produce a very realistic open flame effect that some prefer aesthetically over electric models. However, technology improvements allow electric fireplaces to mimic convincing flames through use of LED lighting, reflection, and flame imagery.
Cost Comparison of Gas vs Electric Fireplaces
One major consideration when switching fireplace types is the cost differences. Here is an overview of typical costs:
| Cost Factor | Gas Fireplace | Electric Fireplace |
|---|---|---|
| Fireplace unit cost | $3,000 – $6,000 installed | $300 – $2,000 |
| Fuel cost per year | $200 – $500 | $50 – $150 |
| Maintenance cost per year | $100 – $300 | Little to none |
| Installation cost | $500 – $2,000+ for venting, gas lines, etc | $0 – $500 for electrical work |
| Lifespan | Up to 20 years | 8-15 years |
Gas fireplaces have a higher upfront equipment and installation cost. Electric fireplaces are cheaper to purchase and install. But electric models may need replacement sooner than long-lasting gas units.
Total Lifetime Costs
The total lifetime costs of gas versus electric can vary greatly based on factors like:
- Fireplace size and features
- Regional utility and fuel rates
- Amount of usage
- Lifespan of unit
- Cost of repairs if needed
Smaller electric fireplace models can potentially have lower total lifetime costs. But for larger, more powerful fireplaces that get extensive use, gas models may end up costing less in the long run.
Choosing Between Gas vs Electric Fireplaces
So should you switch from a gas to an electric fireplace? Here are some guidelines to help decide:
Consider switching to electric if you:
- Want lower upfront costs and easier DIY installation
- Need supplemental heating for small spaces
- Have high annual gas fireplace maintenance fees
- Prefer the convenience and cost savings of electric
- Primarily value the visual effects over intense heat output
Keep your gas fireplace if you:
- Require intense heat to warm larger areas
- Have affordable gas fuel rates and minimal annual fees
- Don’t mind complicated venting and installation requirements
- Prefer the authentic crackling sounds and open flames
- Want a long-lasting heat source and higher resale value
Consultation Recommendations
When deciding between gas and electric fireplaces, it’s wise to consult experts to ensure you make the best choice for your needs, budget, and home:
- Heating and cooling contractors – Get input on heating needs, recommendations on fireplace sizing and models, installation requirements, and cost estimates.
- Fireplace retailers – Discuss available options, costs, appearance considerations, and visibility of various fireplaces.
- Electricians – Assess electrical needs, rewiring requirements, recommended wiring, costs, and safely integrating an electric fireplace.
- Utility companies – Review projected operating costs, incentives, or rebates that may be available.
- Vent installers – If removing gas venting, get professional recommendations on properly abandoning in place or removing.
With input from experts and a full understanding of your needs, preferences, and budget, you can decide if switching from gas to electric makes sense.
Conclusion
Replacing a gas fireplace with an electric model is possible, but involves careful planning regarding installation, heating needs, operating costs, and aesthetics. For some homeowners, the lower upfront price and simpler maintenance of electric fireplaces makes them an attractive alternative to gas. But gas fireplaces still excel at providing intense levels of heat and more realistic flames.
By weighing all the considerations covered here, you can determine if switching to electric makes sense for your specific situation. Be sure to plan installation details carefully with professional help. With the right choice and proper setup, you can enjoy the benefits of gas or electric for creating an inviting focal point and supplemental heat source in your home.