Can you just replace faucet handles?

Replacing faucet handles is a relatively easy DIY project that most homeowners can tackle themselves. The process involves removing the old handles, cleaning the faucet, and installing new handles. With some basic tools and a little time, you can give your bathroom or kitchen faucet an updated look with new handles.

Can I replace handles on my existing faucet?

In most cases, yes, you can replace the handles on your existing faucet without having to replace the entire faucet. As long as the faucet itself is still in good working condition, simply switching out the handles is an easy way to update the look and feel of your fixtures.

Replacing handles is a good option if you like the style and function of your current faucet but want to change the look. It’s also a convenient solution if one of the handles has become damaged or worn out through regular use over time.

What do I need to replace faucet handles?

Replacing faucet handles is a straightforward DIY job. Here are the basic tools and supplies you’ll need:

• New faucet handles that fit your faucet
• Adjustable wrench
• Basin wrench
• Plumber’s putty or silicone sealant
• Putty knife
• Flashlight
• Cloth, towel, or rag
• Pencil

Make sure to check the measurements of your existing handles and purchase replacement handles designed to fit your faucet model. The packaging or product description will specify what type of faucet the handles will work with.

How do I remove old faucet handles?

Start by turning off the water supply to the faucet under the sink. This will prevent water from spraying out when you remove the handles.

Use a cloth or rag to protect the faucet finish from getting scratched. Then check for a set screw or cap on the handle that needs to be loosened with a screwdriver before you can pull the handle off.

If there is no set screw, the handle may be held on with a retaining nut that will need to be loosened with your adjustable wrench or basin wrench.

Wiggle the handle gently side-to-side while pulling up on it. It may take some force to break the seal. Remove any remaining parts still attached to the faucet.

Scrub away any old putty, sealant, or buildup with your rag or a mild abrasive pad to prep the area for your new handles.

How do I measure for new handles?

Once you’ve removed the old handles, take precise measurements of the exposed faucet stems so you can buy replacement handles that fit correctly:

• Measure the diameter of each faucet stem or post.
• Measure the length of the threaded section that the handle screws onto.
• Count the number of threads per inch.
• Measure the distance between the center of each handle post.

Bring these measurements with you when shopping for new handles or look for this info in the product specs online. Getting an accurate fit will ensure the handles install securely and function properly.

How do I install the new handles?

Installation takes a few simple steps:

1. Apply plumber’s putty around the base of each faucet stem. This seals the gap between the new handle and the faucet.
2. Press the new handles into place over the putty. Make sure they are aligned straight.
3. From under the sink, thread any retaining nuts or screws into place to secure the handles and tighten.
4. Turn on the water supply and test the handles to make sure they operate correctly.
5. Wipe away any excess putty that squeezed out.

Take care not to overtighten the retaining nuts or screws since this could damage the faucet. It’s also important to maintain alignment as you tighten the new handles into position.

Helpful tips for replacing handles

Follow these tips to make your faucet handle replacement project go smoothly:

• Plug the sink drain to avoid losing small parts.
• Use a basin wrench if you can’t reach or loosen retaining nuts.
• Wrap plumber’s tape around faucet threads to get a tight seal.
• Clean up any leftover plumber’s putty after the job is done.
• Consider handles with set screws for easier installation.
• Don’t force handles that don’t seem to fit correctly.

Cost to replace faucet handles

If you’re wondering “how much does it cost to replace faucet handles?”, here are some average price estimates:

Handle replacement	Cost
Basic faucet handle pair	$5 – $60
High-end designer handles	$60 – $300+
Plumber installation	$100 – $200 per hour

As you can see, DIY handle replacement can save you a lot compared to hiring a plumber. The handles themselves can cost anywhere from a few dollars for simple plastic handles up to $300 or more for high-end designer styles made of metal, glass, or stone.

FAQ about replacing handles

Do new handles come with everything I need to install them?

Most handle kits include the necessary screws, sealant, and installation hardware. But you’ll need to purchase plumber’s putty separately. Always check the product details to ensure you have everything required for proper installation.

What if my handles are stuck and won’t come off?

Penetrating oil or lubricant can help loosen stuck handles. Let the oil soak in fully before trying again to remove them. Gripping the handles tightly with pliers or a wrench while firmly pulling and wiggling may free them up.

Why do my new handles feel loose?

If newly installed handles wiggle or don’t feel secure, the retaining nuts likely need tightening. It’s important to tighten them enough to keep the handles stable but not overtighten and risk stripping the faucet. Adjust as needed to find the right fit.

Can I just replace one handle and not the pair?

It’s best to replace both handles at the same time, even if only one is currently broken. The unused handle will likely become worn out or damaged over time as well. Replacing both ensures they match and function properly together.

Conclusion

Replacing worn, broken, or outdated faucet handles is an easy and affordable DIY project. In most cases, you can install new handles without replacing the entire faucet. All it takes are some simple tools, measurements, and a little time. With new handles, you can update the style and finish of your bathroom or kitchen fixtures.