When it comes to lawn mowers, homeowners have two main options for riding mowers: stand-on mowers and zero turn mowers. Both offer benefits over push mowers and traditional riding lawn tractors. But which is the better choice – a stand-on or a zero turn mower?
There are pros and cons to both types of mowers. Factors like cutting deck size, maneuverability, slope handling, comfort, and price all come into play when deciding which is the superior option. This article will compare stand-on and zero turn mowers across these criteria to help determine which is the better fit for most homeowners.
Page Contents
Stand-On Mower Overview
Stand-on mowers, sometimes called standers, are a cross between a walk-behind push mower and a riding lawn mower. The operator stands on a platform at the back of the mower, holding onto handlebars similar to a walk-behind mower. But the mower is powered and propelled by a motor and wheels like a riding mower.
Stand-on mowers offer a few key benefits:
– Increased productivity over walk-behinds: The powered drive system means less effort for the operator while covering more ground faster.
– Better maneuverability than lawn tractors: Stand-on mowers have a tighter turn radius, allowing you to more easily mow around trees, landscaping beds, and other obstacles.
– Less space for storage: Stand-on mowers take up less space vertically and can fit through garden gates better than wider zero turn mowers.
– Lower cost than zero turns: While not as inexpensive as push mowers, stand-on mowers cost thousands less than most zero turns.
The trade-offs are that stand-on mowers have smaller cutting decks (typically 30-52 inches) than zero turns and may not provide as smooth of a ride. The standing position also leads to more operator fatigue over long mowing sessions.
Zero Turn Mower Overview
Zero turn mowers, sometimes shortened to z-turn mowers, are riding lawn mowers with a unique dual hydrostatic drive system. This system allows the drive wheels on each side to operate independently from each other.
By driving each wheel in opposite directions, zero turn mowers can spin 360 degrees in place. There is no turning radius – hence the name “zero turn.”
Here are some of the biggest advantages of zero turn mowers compared to stand-on mowers:
– Larger cutting decks (up to 72 inches): The expansive decks on zero turns allow you to mow more grass in a single pass.
– Faster top speed: Zero turns typically reach 6-8 mph at full speed, while stand-on mowers max out around 5 mph.
– Smoother ride: Zero turn mowers have suspension systems and padded seats that provide a more comfortable mowing experience.
– Ability to mow slopes: The dual wheel system provides excellent traction and control for mowing hilly terrain.
The trade-offs for zero turn mowers mainly come down to cost and size. Zero turn mowers start around $3,000 and can exceed $10,000 for commercial models. They are also wider and less nimble than stand-on mowers.
Now that we’ve provided an overview of both mower types, let’s dive deeper into how they compare across some key factors:
Cutting Deck Size
The cutting deck refers to the wide metal housing that encloses and protects the rotating mower blades. Deck size is important because it determines the maximum cut width – or how much grass you can mow in a single pass.
For large, open lawns, bigger decks are better. They allow you to finish mowing faster. Smaller decks require more passes to cover the same amount of ground, increasing mowing time.
*Stand-on mower deck size:*
– 30-52 inches wide
– 36-48 inches most common for homeowners
*Zero turn mower deck size:*
– 36-72 inches wide
– 50-60 inches most common for homeowners
Zero turn mowers offer larger maximum deck sizes up to 72 inches. Their average deck widths are also bigger than stand-on mowers, typically ranging from 50-60 inches. Stand-on mowers max out around 52 inches and usually have 36-48 inch decks.
This allows zero turns to mow significantly more grass before having to make another pass. If you have a large, open yard, a zero turn can finish the job quicker thanks to its wider cutting path.
Maneuverability
Besides cutting width, the other major factor impacting mowing time is maneuverability. The easier a mower can turn and change directions, the faster you can mow around obstacles in your yard.
Stand-on mowers shine when it comes to maneuverability and navigation:
– Tight turn radius: Stand-on mowers have a pivoting rear wheel that allows nearly zero degree turns. This lets you quickly swing around trees, gardens, and other obstructions.
– Compact size: With a narrow stance and small frame, stand-on mowers can fit through backyard gates and easily maneuver in tight spaces.
– Ability to edge and trim: The stand-on platform allows you to hover the mower over beds and edges to cut grass along borders. This saves time on secondary trimming.
Zero turn mowers prioritize cutting width over nimble navigation:
– Wider stance: The dual rear drive wheels are spaced far apart, giving zero turns a wider footprint than stand-on mowers.
– Large frame: The beefy engines, seating area, and expansive decks make zero turns heavier and less compact than stand-on mowers.
– Lacking edging ability: You cannot hover or hang zero turns over planting beds or lawn edges. You’ll still need a dedicated string trimmer.
So while zero turns technically have a zero degree turn radius, their wider stance limits their agility compared to stand-on mowers. For navigating narrow gates or mowing around trees and landscaping, stand-on mowers are the more maneuverable machines.
Slope Handling
Mowing sloped yards presents a challenge for any mower. Stand-on and zero turn mowers both offer advantages for tackling hilly terrain.
For stand-on mowers, the lower center of gravity closer to the ground provides stability on slopes:
– Operator stands near the rear axle, lowering the mower’s center of gravity.
– Allows driving across steep slopes without tipping.
– But still exercise caution on extremely steep hills or embankments.
Zero turn mowers excel on slopes thanks to their dual wheel drive:
– Each rear wheel powers a separate drive motor and hydraulic drive system.
– This provides excellent traction and control up and down sloped yards.
– Allows mowing at angles along the slope rather than just straight up and down.
While stand-on mowers can safely traverse gentle to moderate slopes, most zero turn mowers have a slight edge for mowing more aggressive terrain. Their independent rear wheel control lets them grip the ground better on inclines.
Comfort
In terms of operator comfort, zero turn mowers provide a noticeably smoother ride:
– Padded seat with back support reduces fatigue during long mowing sessions.
– Suspension systems on the rear axle soften bumps across uneven terrain.
– Control levers or steering wheel keep your arms lower and closer to your body.
– Retractable seat bar offers upper body support when backing up.
Stand-on mowers prioritize maneuverability over comfort:
– No seat or suspension leads to jostling and jarring across bumpy yards.
– Standing position taxes lower back and legs after extended use.
– Arms are extended out holding onto stationary handlebars.
– No back support when operating in reverse.
For mowing large properties all day, zero turn mowers lead the way in comfort thanks to their plush seating and smoother ride. Expect more jostling and body fatigue on stand-on mowers after mowing for over an hour.
Price
One of the biggest factors for homeowners deciding between stand-on and zero turn mowers is price:
*Stand-on mower pricing*
– Entry models: $1,500 – $3,000
– Mid-tier models: $3,000 – $4,500
– Commercial models: $4,500 – $6,000
*Zero turn mower pricing*
– Entry residential models: Around $3,000
– Mid-tier residential models: $4,000 – $7,000
– Commercial models: $6,000 – $12,000
While features and deck size impact costs, stand-on mowers are generally thousands less expensive than comparable zero turns. Expect to spend at least $1,000 more for a zero turn over a similar stand-on model.
Keep in mind that more affordable zero turns usually have smaller engines and thinner decks built with residential use in mind. Their commercial zero turn counterparts have beefier builds and higher price tags exceeding $10,000.
Maintenance
In addition to upfront purchase price, long-term maintenance costs are worth considering when choosing between mower types.
Stand-on mowers tend to have lower maintenance costs and needs:
– Smaller and simpler engines than zero turns.
– Less vital fluids and hydrostatic systems to maintain.
– Compact size allowscovered storage to prevent weather damage.
– Average 50-100 maintenance hours before needing service.
Zero turns have more complex components that require diligent care:
– Large engines and integrated hydrostatic systems.
– Multiple fluid reservoirs including gasoline, engine oil, and hydraulic oil.
– Exposure to elements can lead to wear and corrosion.
– Average 25-50 maintenance hours between servicing needs.
While zero turns provide a smoother ride, their higher maintenance requirements lead to more shop time and higher long-term ownership costs compared to stand-on mowers.
Safety
Both stand-on and zero turn mowers come with inherent safety risks that owners must acknowledge.
Potential stand-on mower hazards include:
– Standing operator has less stability than seated position.
– Risk of falling off platform when hitting bumps or slopes.
– Exposed blades pose danger to hands and feet.
– No roll bar or restraint system as protection in the event of a roll-over.
Zero turn mower safety concerns include:
– Easy to lose control if unfamiliar with zero turn mechanism.
– Quick acceleration combined with sharp turning can easily tip mower.
– Exposed blades under large deck can eject debris at high speeds.
– Some light residential models lack roll-over protection.
While zero turns often feel more stable, their high speed and unique steering pose a threat if not respected. Take time to learn the handling of any new mower before operating at full speed. Also use caution on slopes, avoid sharp turns at high speeds, and wear sturdy footwear to protect from blade contact with both machines.
Ease of Use
For first-time riders, zero turn mowers come with a learning curve given their unique dual wheel steering:
– Coordinating the separate drive wheels takes practice.
– Learning precise throttle and steering modulation is essential.
– New operators likely to stall out, peel turf, or lose control at first.
– Recommended to initially use slow speeds for basic maneuvers before going full speed.
Stand-on mowers provide a simpler user experience closer to a walk-behind:
– Basic forward, reverse, and braking handled through a single lever.
– Tight turns executed with familiar steering wheel or handlebars.
– Intuitive standing position like walking behind a mower.
– Less adjustment period needed to become comfortable operating.
Due to their familiar control system, most homeowners can safely operate a stand-on mower with minimal practice. Zero turns require more training time to smoothly coordinate the dual rear wheels pivotal to their operation.
Cut Quality
Cut quality refers to the appearance and health of your lawn after mowing. Both mower types can produce excellent cutting results. Stand-on and zero turn mower cut quality comes down to:
– Blade sharpness: Sharp blades provide clean cuts. Replace or sharpen mower blades regularly.
– Adjustable deck heights: Ability to raise deck for a higher cut or lower it for a precise trim.
– Engine power: Stronger engines able to power blades at consistent speeds, even in thick grass.
– Operator skill: An experienced operator will produce better quality and more uniform cuts.
– Grass type: Some grass varieties respond better to certain heights and cutting frequencies.
Assuming equal blade sharpness and engine power, both machines can achieve a high quality of cut. Deck height adjustment and mowing skill have a larger influence over cut appearance than the type of mower used.
Environmental Impact
Lawn mowers produce emissions and noise that impact the environment:
– Gasoline mower engines emit air pollutants including carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, and volatile organic compounds.
– New EPA regulations have reduced emissions, but gas mowers still release pollutants.
– Electric corded and battery powered mowers produce zero direct emissions.
– Gas engines also generate significant noise ranging from 90-105 dB, well above ambient noise levels.
– Electric mowers produce less noise averaging around 85 dB.
Stand-on and zero turn mowers with gasoline engines have similar environmental impacts. Any gas-powered mower will be louder and release more emissions than electric options. But stand-on mowers tend to use smaller, more efficient engines that may provide slight noise and emissions benefits relative to the large engines on zero turns.
Conclusion
Evaluating the pros and cons, a few key conclusions arise when comparing stand-on vs zero turn mowers:
– For mowing tight, obstacles spaces, stand-on mowers are more maneuverable. Their compact size navigates narrow gates and dense obstacles better.
– Zero turns offer wider cutting decks (50-60” vs 36-48”) that finish open yards quicker with fewer passes.
– Stand-on mowers provide effective slope mowing at a significantly lower price point around $3,000.
– Zero turns deliver superior riding comfort thanks to padded seats, backrests, and suspension.
– More complex transmissions and hydrostatic drive systems on zero turns result in higher maintenance.
– Stand-on mowers allow edging along borders. Their stationary handlebars also provide greater control for meticulous mowing.
– First-time operators will find stand-on mowers easier to use given their familiar walk-behind controls.
So while zero turns hold advantages in cut width, comfort, and heavy slope mowing, stand-on mowers offer greater value and usability for most residential settings. Their lower cost and superior maneuverability in confined yards make stand-on mowers the better choice for homeowners without expansive, wide open grass.
Professional landscapers who mow larger properties all day are better served by zero turn productivity and comfort. But for most homeowners looking for an affordable, user-friendly upgrade over a push mower, stand-on mowers provide the optimal blend of power, efficiency, and value.