When it comes to heating your home, you have a few options to consider. Two of the most popular are gas fireplaces and central heating systems. But which one is more affordable to use? There are several factors to look at when comparing the costs of gas fireplaces versus central heat.
Page Contents
Upfront Costs
The upfront costs of installing a gas fireplace or central heating system can vary greatly depending on the size of your home, the complexity of the installation, your location, and other factors.
Gas fireplaces can range in price from $1,500 for a basic ventless model to $5,000 or more for a top-of-the-line fireplace with customized finishes and high-end features. The average price for installing a mid-range direct-vent gas fireplace is around $3,000.
Meanwhile, installing a new central heating system with a gas furnace, ductwork, vents, and other components can cost $5,000 to $12,000 on average. High-efficiency furnaces and more complex installations may cost $15,000 or more.
So if you’re starting from scratch, a basic gas fireplace may have lower upfront equipment and installation costs than central heating. But upgrading to a larger, more elegant fireplace or adding one to an existing home could cost just as much or more than installing a new furnace and ductwork.
Operating Costs
When it comes to your annual heating bills, there are several variables to consider:
- Home size – Larger homes have higher heating costs
- Climate – Colder regions require more heating
- Insulation – Well-insulated homes retain heat better
- Heating usage – Thermostat settings and lifestyle impact costs
- Efficiency ratings – Higher AFUE scores mean greater efficiency
- Fuel costs – Gas prices fluctuate yearly
Let’s break down some of the key efficiency and usage factors:
Gas Fireplace Efficiency
The annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) of a gas fireplace can range from roughly 50-90%, with the average being around 70%. Higher-end direct vent fireplaces may be 80-90% efficient.
This means for every $1 of gas used, an average fireplace converts 70 cents worth into heat for your home. The rest is lost out the chimney. So gas fireplaces can be less efficient at heating an entire house compared to other options.
Central Heating Efficiency
New gas furnaces are required to have a minimum AFUE of 80%. However, it’s common to see ratings of 90-98% for new models with updated technology. For comparison, an older furnace from the 1980s may only be 60-70% efficient.
So while gas furnaces consume more fuel overall than a single fireplace, 90-95% of that gas gets turned into usable heat. This makes high-efficiency central heating systems one of the most effective ways to heat an entire home.
Heating Usage
Gas fireplaces are often used as a secondary heat source or for ambiance, not as the sole way to heat a home. The average gas fireplace is only used for a few hours per day at a time.
Central heating systems are designed to run extensively to maintain a consistent temperature throughout the house. The central furnace may run for many hours per day during cold weather, especially if you have a large home.
This big difference in usage has a major impact on relative costs. Using a fireplace as supplemental heat typically costs far less than using central heat as the primary heat source.
Operating Cost Comparison
To compare real-world costs, let’s look at some examples for heating a 2,000 sq ft home in Chicago:
Gas Fireplace
- Fireplace size: 40,000 BTU
- Estimated hours used per day: 3
- AFUE rating: 70%
- Gas price: $1.50 per therm
Daily fireplace gas usage = 40,000 BTU x 3 hours = 120,000 BTU
Annual usage = 120,000 BTU/day x 180 days = 21,600,000 BTU
At 70% efficiency, 21,600,000 BTU of gas provides around 15,120,000 BTU of heat.
At $1.50 per therm (100,000 BTU), annual gas cost = $330
Central Heating System
- Furnace size: 100,000 BTU
- Estimated hours used per day: 8
- AFUE rating: 92%
- Gas price: $1.50 per therm
Daily furnace gas usage = 100,000 BTU x 8 hours = 800,000 BTU
Annual usage = 800,000 BTU/day x 180 days = 144,000,000 BTU
At 92% efficiency, 144,000,000 BTU of gas provides around 132,480,000 BTU of heat.
At $1.50 per therm, annual gas cost = $2,160
Cost Comparison
| Heating System | Annual Gas Use | Annual Gas Cost |
| Gas Fireplace | 330 therms | $330 |
| Central Heating | 1440 therms | $2,160 |
Based on typical usage patterns, it’s clear the central heating system uses far more gas to heat the whole home. This results in over 6x higher annual costs compared to using a gas fireplace as a secondary heat source.
Of course, your actual costs may be higher or lower depending on your specific equipment, home size, thermostat settings, and climate. But the comparison shows the dramatic potential savings of using a fireplace judiciously versus central heat for all your heating needs.
Other Factors Impacting Cost
A few other considerations that can affect the affordability comparison:
Maintenance
Gas fireplaces require very little annual maintenance – just cleaning the glass and inspecting the burner. Central heating systems need more upkeep, like replacing filters and getting annual tune-ups.
Repairs
With more components that can fail, central furnaces typically have higher repair and replacement costs over their lifespan.
Fuel Flexibility
Some central heating systems can be dual-fueled and switched to propane as needed. Fireplaces are usually natural gas only.
Home Resale Value
Gas fireplaces and central heat can both add value and make homes more attractive to buyers.
Conclusion
Based on the cost comparison above, gas fireplaces are generally more affordable to operate than central heating:
- Lower equipment costs in some cases
- Much lower annual gas usage and expenses
- Minimal maintenance requirements
However, central heating systems have a key advantage in their ability to effectively heat an entire home. Gas fireplaces alone may not be able to maintain comfortable temperatures throughout larger houses.
The most cost-effective and practical option for many homeowners is to use a gas fireplace alongside central heating. Run the central furnace as needed to warm the whole home, while using the fireplace a few hours a day for zonal heating and ambiance. This balanced approach provides comfort and affordability.