Steam bending is a technique that has been used for centuries to bend and shape wood. It involves using steam to make the wood pliable so it can be bent around forms to create curved and rounded shapes. But does this process compromise the strength and durability of the wood? Here is an in-depth look at whether steam bent wood is strong.
Page Contents
How Steam Bending Works
Steam bending works by using steam to soften the lignin in the wood fibers. Lignin is the natural glue that holds the wood fibers together. When exposed to steam, the lignin softens, allowing the wood fibers to become pliable and bendable without breaking or fracturing.
There are a few different methods of steam bending wood:
- A wood piece can be placed over a boiling pot of water or steam box. The steam penetrates and softens the wood.
- A pipe or tube can be used to direct steam right onto the surface of the wood.
- A water-filled blanket or bag can be applied to the wood to create a steaming environment.
Once steamed and pliable, the wood is then clamped or held in position over a form or mold. As it dries, it will hold the new curved shape. This allows wood to be shaped into complex bends and curves that would otherwise cause the wood to snap under pressure.
Effect of Steam Bending on Wood Strength
There are a few considerations when it comes to how steam bending impacts wood strength:
Wood Softening
The steaming process does result in a temporary softening and weakening of the wood. This allows it to bend without cracking and splitting. However, as the wood dries, the lignin resets and the wood fibers bond back together. This restores much of the wood’s original strength and rigidity.
Grain Direction
The grain direction is important when steam bending. For the strongest result, the wood grain should follow the outside curve of the bend, rather than cross the curve. This prevents the wood fibers on the outer section from fracturing and weakening.
Wood Species
Certain wood species are better suited for steam bending. Woods like white oak, ash, hickory, and walnut bend well. Softwoods like pine and fir do not respond as well to steam bending. Harder woods with longer wood fibers typically regain more strength after bending. The wood species is a factor in the final strength of a steam bent piece.
Cracks and Fractures
Care must be taken when steam bending to avoid cracks, fractures, and splits in the wood. Any defects like this will result in weakened areas. Gentle bending and proper clamping or shaping helps minimize cracks and splits.
Design and Shape
The degree and tightness of the bend will impact strength. Gentle sweeping curves retain more strength than sharp, tight bends. Proper design is important to prevent overly stressed areas.
Advantages of Steam Bending
When done properly, steam bending offers several advantages:
- Bends wood into shapes not possible by other means
- Minimizes cracks and fractures from shaping
- Retains much of the original strength of the wood
- Less wasted wood than cutting curved shapes
- Attractive and flowing curves and shapes
Steam Bent Wood Strength Testing
There have been some studies done to test and quantify the strength of steam bent wood pieces compared to non-bent wood pieces:
Study 1: Three-Point Bending Tests
One study subjected steam bent oak pieces and straight oak pieces to three-point bending tests to failure. The results showed only a 15% decrease in the bending strength of steamed-bent oak compared to non-bent pieces. This indicates the steam bending process results in only minor loss of strength.
Study 2: Ash Bend Strength Testing
Another lab tested steamed white ash that was bent to 45 and 90 degree angles. The bent ash samples were subject to bending and compression strength testing and then compared to straight white ash samples. The results showed a very slight 5-10% decrease in strength for the bent ash samples.
Study 3: Impact Testing
A study tested steam bent oak by subjecting it to impact blows from a hammer. The bent oak withstood considerable impact force before failure, demonstrating good strength retention after bending.
While more extensive strength testing is still needed, these initial studies indicate steam bent wood retains a high percentage of its original strength and integrity, when done properly.
Steam Bending Wood for Strength
Based on current knowledge and testing, here are some tips for steam bending wood while preserving as much strength as possible:
- Select strong wood species suited for bending, like white oak, ash, hickory, and walnut.
- Ensure the wood grain follows the curve rather than crosses it.
- Use gradual smooth curves rather than tight sharp bends.
- Avoid cracks, fractures, or defects during the bending process.
- Allow the wood to dry completely after bending to regain stiffness.
- Consider reinforcing bends with splines, laminations, or metal fasteners.
- Use proper engineering and design to minimize stress points.
Is Steam Bent Wood Suitable for Structural Applications?
Steam bent wood retains a high degree of its strength after bending. However, for structural applications where bent wood will be subject to heavy loads, steam bent wood may not be the ideal choice. Some considerations for structural steam bent wood include:
- The bend area is the weakest point and may fail before non-bent areas.
- Heavy beams or posts may split at the bend points under high compression loads.
- Sharp bends induce stress concentrations that can weaken and crack the wood.
- Bent wood beams can sag slightly over time at the bend points, losing strength.
For most residential applications like railings, furniture, cabinetry and decorative molding, steam bent wood provides ample strength. But for heavy-duty structural applications, steam bent wood may fall short for reasons above. Each case depends on the specifics of the design and engineering requirements.
Conclusion
When performed with care using suitable wood species, steam bending results in only minor reductions in strength, typically no more than 15%. The wood fibers regain much of their original bonding strength once dried into shape. For lighter-duty applications, steam bent wood provides adequate strength and brings the advantages of flowing curves not possible otherwise. The aesthetics and workability of steam bending will continue gaining popularity for furniture and decorative uses. For more demanding structural supports, steam bent wood may require bracing, reinforcement, and careful engineering evaluation to determine if adequate strength can be achieved and maintained over the long term.