Having a garage door that closes automatically after being opened is a convenient feature that many homeowners desire. Self-closing garage doors provide some nice benefits, but also have some downsides to consider. Let’s take an in-depth look at the pros and cons of self-closing garage doors to help determine if this feature is right for your home.
Page Contents
What is a self-closing garage door?
A self-closing garage door is designed to close automatically after being opened, usually within a preset time such as 30 seconds or 1 minute. The door will close on its own without someone having to hit the wall switch or remote control again to activate the closing function.
This type of garage door has sensors that detect when the door reaches the fully open position. Once in the open position, a timer starts and when the preset time is up, the sensors will trigger the door to start closing automatically.
There are a few different ways this can be accomplished:
- Using an automatic closing mechanism built into the garage door opener system. This is a common method for newer garage door openers.
- Installing an add-on automatic closing device that attaches to the existing manual garage door. This allows older doors to be upgraded to self-closing.
- Using an advanced control panel on the garage door motor that has self-closing capabilities.
No matter which method is used, the door should fully close on its own within a consistent time frame every time it’s opened.
Benefits of self-closing garage doors
There are some excellent reasons why many homeowners find value in having an automatic closing garage door:
- Convenience – By far the biggest benefit is the convenience factor. You simply hit the opener and walk inside without having to wait around for the door to fully close and then hit the button again. This allows you to get inside quicker and not have to worry about the door being left open.
- Reduced energy costs – An insulated garage door that self-closes means less cold or hot outside air will enter the garage space. This can lead to energy savings from your heating and cooling system not having to work as hard.
- Increased safety & security – There is less risk of theft with a door that closes promptly every time. This added security can provide peace of mind.
- Avoid door damage – If everyone in the household knows the door closes by itself, there will be fewer instances of accidentally leaving the door up for long periods of time. This reduces wear and tear.
- Emergency closing – Advanced garage door openers with battery backup allow the door to still close automatically during power outages. This ensures the door is closed in an emergency situation.
- Better pest control – Bugs, rodents and other pests are less likely to enter through an open garage if the door closes right away each use.
These valuable benefits make upgrading to a self-closing system an attractive option for many homeowners.
Potential downsides of self-closing garage doors
Although self-closing garage doors provide a lot of useful benefits, there are some potential drawbacks to weigh as well:
- Higher upfront cost – Adding an automatic closing mechanism will typically cost more than a standard manual garage door. There is both material and labor expense involved, which may range from $100-$500 depending on the solution used.
- Occasional maintenance – The sensors and closing timer that control the automatic function will need periodic maintenance and calibration to keep working reliably. This may require hiring a professional.
- Danger of entrapment – Improperly adjusted sensors can fail to reverse the door if an obstruction is detected. Always use a reputable installer and follow all safety precautions.
- Nuisance closings – Occasionally the door may close unexpectedly if you need to step in and out of the garage quickly. This can be frustrating.
- Loud noise – Some self-closing mechanisms generate loud noises and vibrations as they automatically shut the door. This may be disruptive.
Carefully weighing both the pros and cons of self-closing doors based on your needs and preferences is recommended.
Best practices for self-closing garage doors
If you decide to have an automatic closing garage door installed, following these best practices will provide optimal convenience, safety and performance:
- Hire a qualified, licensed garage door professional to handle the installation and programming.
- Make sure the automatic close timer is set appropriately, usually to between 30-90 seconds.
- Test and adjust the sensitivity of the safety sensors so the door reverses properly if obstructed.
- Consider installing battery backup on the motor system to allow self-closing during power failures.
- Have the door serviced annually to check balance, lubricate parts and confirm proper sensor functionality.
- Think about adding flashing lights and an alarm to alert when the door is closing.
- Never let children or pets play near the door during operation.
- Avoid standing directly in the path of the door as it closes.
Following safety measures and manufacturer recommended maintenance for the model of door installed is highly recommended for optimal, safe operation.
Key considerations when choosing self-closing
If you’re still undecided whether a self-closing garage door is right for your home, think about these key factors:
- How often will you utilize the opening and closing function each day?
- Do you normally stay within sight of the door when it’s open?
- Is your garage detached or attached to the home?
- Do you have any concerns about the door closing too quickly?
- Will automation provide needed convenience or more frustration?
Your answers to these questions will help guide you to the best decision for your unique needs and preferences.
Installation costs for self-closing garage doors
Here are typical price ranges for adding self-close capability to an existing or new garage door:
| Self-close Solution | Typical Cost |
|---|---|
| Automatic opener add-on device | $100 – $300 |
| Built-in automatic closer kit | $250 – $500 |
| New opener system with self-close | $400 – $750 |
| New door/opener package with self-close | $1,000 – $1,500 |
Labor expenses will add about $100-$200 for installation. Ongoing maintenance ranges from $20-$75 annually.
Conclusion
When it comes to the question of whether residential garage doors should automatically close themselves, there are good arguments on both sides. For many homeowners, the increased convenience and efficiency outweigh the higher costs. If you do opt for self-closing, make sure to have qualified pros handle the installation and follow all safety advice from the manufacturer.
With an understanding of the pros and cons, you can decide if the extra functionality of self-closing garage doors seems beneficial for your household. Careful selection of quality equipment and professional service will help ensure years of safe, reliable operation.