Should I remove my storm door?

What is a storm door?

A storm door is an additional door installed in front of an exterior access door to protect against weather elements and provide insulation. Storm doors typically have a metal or vinyl frame with a large glass panel to allow you to see outside. They also often have a retractable screen panel that allows air flow while keeping out insects. Storm doors create an air pocket between the storm door and main door that acts as insulation. This can help reduce drafts and improve energy efficiency.

Benefits of a storm door

There are several benefits to having a storm door installed:

• Improved insulation – The air gap between a storm door and main door provides an extra layer of insulation. This can reduce heat loss in winter and heat gain in summer.
• Protection from weather – Storm doors shield your main entry door from rain, snow, wind and other elements. This protects your door from water damage, swelling and warping.
• Added security – Storm doors often feature strong metal or vinyl frames with tempered safety glass. This provides an extra barrier against intruders attempting to force the main door open.
• Improved pest control – Retractable screens allow air circulation while preventing bugs and insects from entering your home.
• Increased light – Many storm doors have full glass panels to let natural light into an entryway.
• Enhanced curb appeal – Attractive storm doors can improve the look of an entryway and add to your home’s curb appeal.

Installing a quality storm door is an easy way to upgrade your entryway while also improving your home’s weather proofing, security, appearance and energy efficiency.

Disadvantages of storm doors

However, there are some potential downsides to storm doors that you may want to consider:

• Cost – While storm door prices can vary widely based on the quality and features, they are an added upfront investment that can range from $200-$1000 or more.
• Maintenance – Storm doors are subject to wear and tear from use and exposure to weather. Their moving parts like hinges and retractable screens may need occasional repair or replacement.
• Aesthetics – If a storm door is noticeably different than the main entry door in design, color or proportions, it could potentially detract from the look of the home’s facade.
• Condensation issues – Humid indoor air condenses on the interior glass or metal panels of storm doors. Managing moisture and allowing for proper airflow is important.
• Wood warping – Exterior wood doors behind storm doors are still subject to some moisture and may warp over time. Occasional inspection and maintenance is required.
• Difficulty removing – Storm doors are secured firmly to doorframes and removing them can be challenging or result in damage if not done properly.

These potential disadvantages should be carefully weighed when deciding whether to add a storm door or remove an existing one.

Reasons to remove a storm door

There are a few scenarios where removing an existing storm door may be warranted:

• Frequent issues – If the storm door is repeatedly damaged, lets in water or drafts, has failing hardware or requires constant repairs, replacement may make more sense than continued maintenance.
• Moisture problems – Poor airflow resulting in condensation between a storm door and main door can cause moisture issues like mold, rot, or wood warping.
• Safety hazards – Old or damaged glass panels that are weakened or fracture could pose a safety risk.
• Pest entry – Gaps or holes in retractable screens can allow easy pest access into the home.
• Aesthetics – A dated or poorly fitting storm door can detract from updated exterior facades or new entry doors.
• Difficult access – Storm doors that impede mobility access for strollers, wheelchairs or walkers may need removal.

If your storm door exhibits any of these issues, taking it down and replacing with a new one or doing without may be your best option.

How to remove a storm door

Removing an existing storm door takes time, patience and proper tools. Here are the basic steps:

1. Remove the door sweeps at the bottom of the storm door thresholds using a flathead screwdriver. Set them aside for potential reuse.
2. Unlatch the storm door from the door frame using the interior and exterior door handle mechanisms. This will disengage the compression or snap fittings.
3. Unscrew any screws, typically located at the top and bottom of the hinge side, securing the storm door frame to the exterior door frame using a drill/driver. Close the main door while doing this.
4. Detach the storm door from the main door frame by lifting up on the door to release the interlock. You may need to gently pry it loose by inserting a flat bar or putty knife into the seam.
5. Remove any remaining screws around the frame. Older storm doors may be attached using nail strips that require prying off with a hammer and pry bar.
6. Lift the now detached storm door out of the opening using an assistant or temporary support beneath it. Set it aside somewhere safe.
7. Use sandpaper to smooth down any uneven holes, old caulk or nails left over on the door frame.
8. Consider capping unused screw holes and treat any exposed unfinished wood with protective sealer.
9. Properly dispose of the old storm door if it will not be reused.

Always wear protective gloves and eyewear when removing a storm door. Go slowly and take care not to damage the surrounding frame or main door.

Should you install a new storm door?

Once you’ve removed an old storm door, decide if replacing it with a new one makes sense:

• If moisture issues were present, ensure the main door and surrounding framing are repaired first before installing a new storm door.
• Consider whether your home’s current design scheme and color palette would be complemented by a storm door addition.
• Factor in the energy efficiency rating of your current exterior door before expecting a storm door to provide substantial savings.
• Evaluate whether a new storm door’s cost aligns with the value it will add to your home through appearance, protection or weather proofing.
• Understand that installing a quality storm door that operates smoothly requires precision measurements and proper anchoring to the door frame.

Replacement provides an opportunity to upgrade to a newer style of storm door featuring sleeker lines, tempered glass, sturdier construction and easier installation. Going without is also an option if your main entry door already provides sufficient insulation and protection.

Best alternatives to storm doors

For those choosing to forego a new storm door, consider these effective alternatives for your entryway:

• Install sidelights or transom windows around a main entry door to allow light while maintaining security.
• Choose an insulated fiberglass or steel exterior door with a high energy efficiency rating.
• Add weather stripping around the door’s edges to seal air gaps.
• Repair or replace threshold seals beneath entry doors.
• Install a retractable screen door that provides ventilation without sacrificing visibility.
• Plant foliage like bushes or trellises to create an air buffer zone in front of entryways.
• Construct a small covered porch or extended roof overhang to protect the entry from above.

Conclusion

Storm doors can provide worthwhile benefits but also come with potential drawbacks. Assessing your current entry door situation and home’s needs is important in deciding whether storm door removal, replacement or an alternative makes the most sense. If pursuing removal, take precautions against damaging the surrounding door frame. Consider energy efficiency upgrades to your main door if you choose to go without a storm door. With proper planning and care, you can implement the ideal entryway solution for your home.