A shower tub combo, also known as a tub-shower combo, is a bathroom fixture that combines a bathtub and a shower stall into one unit. This space-saving design allows you to take either a bath or a shower in the same location. While shower tub combos provide versatility and convenience, they also come with some potential drawbacks compared to having separate shower stalls and bathtubs. In this article, we’ll explore the main cons of shower tub combos to consider if you’re deciding whether this type of fixture is right for your bathroom remodel or new construction project.
Page Contents
- 1 Limited space for showering
- 2 Water leaks and moisture issues
- 3 Compromised soaking experience
- 4 Difficulty keeping clean
- 5 Reduced accessibility
- 6 Lower resale value
- 7 Not suitable for some bathrooms
- 8 Conclusion
- 9 Factors influencing the cons of shower tub combos
- 10 Tips for minimizing the cons of shower tub combos
- 11 Alternatives to shower tub combos
- 12 Key takeaways
Limited space for showering
One of the biggest complaints about shower tub combos is that they provide a cramped showering area. With both a tub and shower crammed into the space, there’s often limited elbow room to move around and properly rinse off. Standard bathtubs are only 60 inches long, meaning shower tub combos are typically smaller than a dedicated shower stall. For larger individuals or families that need more generous showering capacity, the tight quarters of a shower tub combo may be frustrating and inconvenient on a daily basis.
Water leaks and moisture issues
The seam between the tub and shower walls in a combo fixture can be prone to leaking. Water may drip through cracks onto the bathroom floor, causing moisture damage over time if left unaddressed. The leakage problems are often exacerbated by improper installation or aging and wear of the caulking seals. Also, when shower spray hits the tub surround, it’s common for water to escape and puddle on the floor. The moisture can lead to growth of mold, mildew and bacteria if ventilation is inadequate.
Compromised soaking experience
While a shower tub combo allows you to take a bath, the experience is often compromised compared to a spacious freestanding tub. The cramped dimensions limit your ability to fully stretch out and relax in the bath. Standard tubs built into a combo are also typically relatively shallow, reducing soaking capacity. And features like contoured lumbar support and jetted hydrotherapy that enhance the bathing ritual aren’t available in a basic shower tub fixture.
Difficulty keeping clean
The crevices between the tub and shower enclosure in a combo can trap dirt, hair and soap scum. This can lead to grimy build-up that’s difficult to access and clean. Mold and mildew growth in the cracks is also a problem if moisture isn’t wiped out after every use. Fully cleaning a shower tub combo typically requires more diligent scrubbing than a separate tub and shower to prevent unsightly residues.
Reduced accessibility
A shower tub combo generally doesn’t provide the same level of accessibility as a walk-in shower. The high walls to step over and slippery surface make it more difficult to enter and exit safely. This causes a particular issue for the elderly, disabled or those with mobility limitations who would benefit from a curbless and doorless shower design. While some combo units have low-threshold doors and grab bars added, they still don’t supply the complete ADA compliance of a proper walk-in shower.
Lower resale value
In general, shower tub combos may not add as much value to a home as having a distinct shower and soaking tub. They look more basic and utilitarian versus upscale and spa-like. For homeowners looking to sell in the future, a bathroom with a combo unit rather than an elegant stand-alone tub may be seen as more dated and less desirable. If considering resale, a shared shower and tub often isn’t the prime choice.
Not suitable for some bathrooms
Depending on the size and layout of your bathroom, a shower tub combo may not be the right fit. Small or narrow bathrooms may have trouble accommodating the typical 60-inch tub length. Sloping ceilings and attics converted to bathrooms also often can’t handle the height of a combined tub and shower. If your available bathroom space is limited, then choosing this fixture may not be feasible.
Conclusion
While shower tub combos provide the versatility of both bathing and showering in one fixture, they also come with some distinct drawbacks. The most significant cons to weigh are the cramped showering space, risk of leaks, difficult cleaning and reduced resale value compared to separate shower and tub options. However, if you’re working with a small bathroom and value the convenience of an all-in-one fixture, a shower tub combo may still suit your needs. Carefully consider the pros and cons based on your space, bathing preferences and budget to decide if one is your best option. With proper installation and maintenance, a combo can be a relatively affordable and practical way to add both showering and soaking capacity to your bathroom.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Space-saving design | Limited elbow room for showering |
| Allows for both baths and showers | Prone to leakage and moisture issues |
| Often more affordable than separate fixtures | Compromised soaking experience |
| Simple to clean compared to two separate fixtures | Difficult to fully clean crevices |
| Easy to install as a single unit | Reduced accessibility compared to walk-in showers |
| Takes up less floor space than two fixtures | May reduce resale value versus upscale separate tub and shower |
| May not fit in all bathroom layouts and sizes |
Factors influencing the cons of shower tub combos
There are several factors that can influence the degree of cons experienced with a shower tub combo:
Installation quality
Poor installation often exacerbates issues like leaks. Proper sealing during install is crucial.
Size and layout of bathroom
Small, cramped bathrooms make the limited space of a combo more problematic.
Number of users
Households with multiple people needing to shower may find the tight quarters unsuitable.
Types of users
Elderly, disabled or others with mobility limitations will be most impacted by accessibility issues.
Frequency of use
Frequent showering and bathing makes cleanliness and mold issues more apparent.
Quality of combo unit
Cheaper acrylic models tend to have more durability and leakage problems than higher-end enameled steel.
Caulking maintenance
Regular re-caulking is needed to prevent leaks as seals age.
Ventilation
Lack of exhaust fans, windows and air circulation increase condensation and moisture problems.
Cleaning practices
Frequent and thorough scrubbing is required to prevent dirt and scum buildup in crevices.
Water pressure
Excessive pressure can lead to more spraying and escaping water during showers.
Tips for minimizing the cons of shower tub combos
If you decide a shower tub combo is the right choice for your home, there are ways to help mitigate some of the disadvantages:
– Choose high-quality materials like enameled cast iron rather than cheaper acrylic.
– Properly seal connections with silicone caulk during installation.
– Install an exterior shower curtain as well as interior liner to contain spray.
– Install a really good exhaust fan to minimize moisture issues.
– Keep the caulking clean, dry and regularly maintained.
– Use anti-mold bathroom paint and caulk to prevent mildew growth.
– Frequently wipe down walls and surfaces after showering.
– Keep cleaning products handy to scrub tile crevices and tub rims.
– Use a squeegee after showering to keep glass and walls dry.
– Open windows during and after bathing to allow air circulation.
– Have professional re-grouting done if cracks appear between tiles.
– Seal any small leaks promptly to prevent moisture damage.
– Limit high-pressure shower heads that cause excessive overspray.
Alternatives to shower tub combos
If the drawbacks of a shower tub combo seem too significant, here are some alternative options to consider:
Separate tub and shower
Installing a distinct shower stall and soaking tub can provide the best of both bathing worlds without compromises.
Walk-in shower
A doorless design with curbless entry is the most accessible and leak-proof shower option.
Freestanding tub
This elegant and spacious soaking tub style allows for a shower stall in the same bathroom.
Bathroom addition
If space allows, adding a separate new half or full bathroom can accommodate both tub and shower needs.
Wet room
A fully waterproofed bathroom with integrated shower and floor drain provides maximum openness.
Bidet
Installing a bidet provides an additional hygiene option beyond just the tub/shower.
Key takeaways
– The major cons of shower tub combos are limited shower space, leaks, cleaning difficulties and reduced resale value.
– Small bathrooms, improper installation, lack of ventilation and inadequate cleaning contribute to the disadvantages.
– Careful maintenance and design choices can help minimize potential shower tub combo problems.
– Separate tub and shower or a new bathroom addition are alternatives for those wanting the best standalone experiences.
– Overall, the pros and cons come down to your specific bathroom space and how you plan to use the shower tub fixture.