When looking at a toaster, you’ll likely see some numbers marked on the side or top. These numbers refer to different toasting settings that allow you to customize how light or dark you want your toast. The numbers correspond to the amount of time the bread will spend inside the toaster, with higher numbers resulting in darker toast.
Page Contents
Common Toaster Settings
Most toasters have settings ranging from 1 to 7, with 1 producing very light toast and 7 producing very dark toast bordering on burnt. Some common settings you may see include:
- 1-2: Very light toast, just warmed through
- 3: Light toast, lightly browned
- 4: Medium toast, lightly browned on both sides
- 5-6: Darker toast, browned more substantially on both sides
- 7: Very dark or burnt toast
The exact numbering and darkness levels can vary slightly between toaster models. For example, some may go up to setting 10 for an extremely dark toast. But in general, lower numbers mean lighter toast and higher numbers mean darker toast.
Factors That Affect Toasting
Several factors beyond just the toaster setting can impact how light or dark your toast turns out:
- Type of bread: Some breads toast faster and darker than others. Whole grain and healthier breads generally toast quicker and darker than white bread.
- Freshness of bread: Fresher bread will make lighter toast than older, drier bread.
- Thickness of slices: Thicker slices will require longer toasting times than thinner slices.
- Moisture content: Bread with higher moisture content takes longer to toast.
- Toaster mechanics: Some toasters heat more evenly and quickly than others, impacting toast darkness.
Because of these factors, you’ll need to adjust the toaster setting depending on the specifics of your bread. You may need a darker setting for whole wheat versus white bread, or for thicker versus thinner slices. Get to know your toaster and bread combinations.
Toaster Settings for Common Foods
While toast is the most obvious use for a toaster, you can also toast many other foods in them. Here are some guidelines for toaster settings when toasting foods besides bread:
| Food | Recommended Toaster Setting |
|---|---|
| Bagels | 4-5 |
| English Muffins | 3-5 |
| Waffles or Pancakes | 3-4 |
| Pastries (pop tarts, muffins, etc) | 3-4 |
Keep in mind that just like bread, factors like moisture content and thickness will affect the toasting time needed for these other foods. Get to know the right setting for your toaster and preferred level of crispiness.
Toaster Settings for Frozen Foods
Some toasters have a specific frozen setting that allows you to toast frozen foods like waffles, pastries, or bread. This activates a longer toasting time at a lower temperature to gently thaw and toast the food. If your toaster doesn’t have a frozen button, just use a slightly lower numbered setting than you normally would.
Here are some guidelines for toasting frozen foods:
- Frozen bread: Set the toaster to 3 or the “frozen” setting.
- Frozen waffles or pastries: Set the toaster to 2 or the “frozen” setting.
- Monitor closely and increase the setting if needed. Foods may require an extra cycle if very frozen.
Getting the Perfect Toast
It may take some trial and error to find your perfect toast setting, but keeping these tips in mind can help:
- Start in the middle with a setting around 4 and adjust from there.
- Remember the type of bread and thickness of slice affects toasting time.
- Allow the toaster to completely cool between cycles or slices.
- If toasting multiple slices, use a lower setting to avoid uneven toasting.
- Use a dedicated setting for frozen foods if available, or reduce your normal setting.
- Don’t peek by opening the toaster mid-cycle, which can cause uneven toasting.
With some experimentation, you’ll find your ideal toaster settings for everything from lightly golden toast to crispy bagels. Just be careful not to burn the bread or set off any smoke alarms in pursuit of toast perfection!
Toaster Setting Recommendations
Here are some recommended toaster settings from Reddit users for getting the perfect toast with different types of breads:
White Bread
- “3 is perfect for getting white bread lightly browned without drying it out.”
- “I use 2 for a light toast on white.”
- “Setting 4 gives white bread a nice golden brown for me. Anything higher starts to burn.”
Whole Wheat/Grain Bread
- “I use 5 for 100% whole wheat bread. 4 is too light and pale.”
- “6 is my go-to for darker, grainier breads.”
- “Whole grain is best at 4-5 for an even crispness.”
Sourdough Bread
- “I do sourdough at setting 5 since it tends to brown faster.”
- “Setting 3 or 4 works well for me with sourdough to get some color without drying it out.”
- “Because of the moisture in sourdough, I use setting 6 for a nice toasted crust.”
Gluten-Free Bread
- “Gluten-free bread toasts fast so I only use setting 2-3.”
- “I keep gluten-free bread on 3 max. Any higher and it burns.”
- “Setting 4 gives my gluten-free bread a nice crunch without over-toasting.”
Thick Breads/Bagels
- “Thick slices of artisan bread need setting 6 for even toasting.”
- “I use 5 or 6 for bagels to fully crisp the outer layer.”
- “Setting 7 works best for me for thick bakery-style breads.”
Toaster Settings to Avoid
While personal taste for toast darkness varies, there are some toaster settings you’ll generally want to avoid:
- 1-2: Won’t fully toast and dry out bread
- 7+: Will burn and dry out the toast
- Frozen setting for non-frozen items: Produces under-toasted bread
- High settings for quick-toasting breads like gluten-free: Can burn
Anything set too high can risk burnt, smoking toast which can set off smoke alarms. Settings too low may warm but not fully dehydrate and crisp the bread. Find the right middle ground for optimal toast!
How to Troubleshoot Your Toaster
If you’re having issues getting your toaster to brown bread evenly or to your desired darkness level, there are a few tricks to troubleshoot:
- Clean out crumbs which can impede heat circulation
- Adjust the browning control dial to a higher setting
- Allow toaster to fully cool between uses
- Do not open the toaster mid-cycle
- Use a dedicated setting for frozen items
- Replace the crumb tray if damaged/warped
- Adjust the bread guides to hold thinner slices in place
- Gently bend or rotate bread slices to expose all sides evenly
- Test toaster with known fresh, thinly sliced bread
- Have toaster serviced or replaced if issues persist
Conclusion
The numbers on a toaster correspond to the browning setting, with lower numbers producing lighter toast and higher numbers darker toast. Most standard toasters have settings ranging from 1-7, with 4-6 toasting bread to a typical golden brown level. Factors like bread type, slice thickness, and moisture impact how quickly bread toasts. With some trial and adjustment to find the right setting for your tastes and bread choices, you can easily achieve toasty, golden brown perfection.