An arc fault circuit interrupter (AFCI) is a special type of circuit breaker designed to detect and respond to dangerous electrical arcs in home wiring. AFCIs help prevent electrical fires by shutting off power when an arc fault is detected. However, like any electrical device, AFCIs can malfunction or go bad over time. This article will examine what can happen when an AFCI breaker fails and no longer provides adequate protection. We’ll look at the potential risks, troubleshooting tips, and when it’s time to replace a defective AFCI breaker. Having a properly functioning AFCI is critical for home safety, so it’s important to understand their operation and know the signs of a failing breaker.
Page Contents
What is an AFCI Breaker?
An arc fault circuit interrupter serves as a sensitive circuit breaker that knows the difference between safe and unsafe electricity flow. A standard circuit breaker will only trip when it detects an overload or short circuit. However, dangerous high-temperature electrical arcing in damaged wires or cords will not necessarily draw enough current to trip the breaker. An arc fault causes intense localized heat, which can easily ignite nearby combustible materials like wood or insulation. This potential fire hazard is what AFCIs are designed to prevent.
AFCI breakers contain sophisticated electronics that can detect the unique electrical noise signature of an arc fault. When it senses this irregular pattern, the AFCI interrupts the circuit very quickly to prevent a fire from starting. Without this specialized protection, dangerous arcs can go undetected. Since arc faults only draw about 5 to 10 amps, they will likely operate below the overload threshold of a normal 15 or 20 amp circuit breaker. So AFCIs provide an extra layer of protection.
Where Are AFCI Breakers Required?
AFCI breakers have been required in new home construction since the 1999 edition of the National Electrical Code (NEC). The 2008 NEC edition greatly expanded the AFCI requirements to include all 15 and 20 amp, 120 volt circuits supplying outlets in dwelling unit bedrooms. This ensures protection for all bedroom receptacles and lighting circuits. More recent code editions have further expanded the circuits requiring AFCI protection. Beginning with the 2022 NEC, all 15 and 20 amp, 120-volt dwelling unit circuits will require AFCIs. As existing homes are renovated, these codes also require AFCI breakers be installed to replace conventional breakers.
What Happens When an AFCI Breaker Fails?
When an AFCI breaker fails or malfunctions, it ceases to provide the vital protection it was designed for. This leaves the home’s electrical system vulnerable to an undetected arcing condition that could lead to fire. There are a few different failure scenarios:
Nuisance Tripping
An AFCI that trips off frequently or at random intervals for no apparent reason is clearly experiencing some kind of malfunction. This nuisance tripping is annoying and disruptive. More importantly, you can’t rely on a breaker that trips unpredictably to do its job when a real arc fault occurs. Frequent nuisance tripping indicates it’s time to replace the defective AFCI.
Failure to Trip
Just as concerning as nuisance tripping is when an AFCI fails to trip at all, even when a known arc fault exists. This scenario can occur if the breaker’s sensing electronics become damaged or defective. Routine testing and inspection of AFCIs involves using a test button on the breaker to simulate an arc fault. When this test button no longer causes the breaker to trip, it means the AFCI is no longer working properly. A failure to trip on this test requires immediate breaker replacement.
No Power With No Tripping
Another failure mode is when an AFCI breaker suddenly stops supplying power to the circuit with no tripping occurring. The breaker may appear on but simply fails to flow electricity. This again indicates a malfunction requiring replacement. But it also means the circuit is currently unprotected from any arc faults, since opening the main contacts is how the AFCI interrupts power when it senses an arc.
Risks of a Defective AFCI Breaker
The risks of an AFCI breaker that has stopped functioning properly primarily relate to fire safety. Key risks include:
Undetected Arcing
The core job of an AFCI is to detect hazardous electrical arcing and quickly de-energize the circuit. But if the electronics fail or cannot sense an arc, this protection disappears. Arcing from damaged wiring or cords can go unnoticed, potentially igniting surrounding materials. This eliminates the fire prevention benefit that AFCIs are designed to provide.
Delayed Tripping
While an AFCI that fully fails to trip is the worst case, there are also risks if it merely trips slower than intended. These breakers are designed to interrupt arcs extraordinarily quickly, within a fraction of a second. But a defective breaker may respond sluggishly and trip open much slower when it finally detects an arcing condition. This delayed reaction time allows the arc to persist longer, potentially increasing fire risks.
Limited Fire Detection
Along with arc faults, AFCIs also provide enhanced fire detection in some cases. Some designs can detect the electrical effects of flames or high temperatures during a fire’s initial stages. This allows the breaker to trip due to the fire itself, even if arcing wasn’t the initial source. But again, if the AFCI electronics are impaired, this supplemental detection ability is compromised. It cannot alert occupants or emergency services to an electrical fire without power being cut.
Signs of a Failing AFCI Breaker
Detecting when an AFCI breaker begins underperforming or malfunctioning is critical for safety. Here are key signs of a potentially defective breaker:
Nuisance Tripping
As mentioned earlier, frequent tripping of an AFCI at seemingly random intervals indicates there is a problem. Even if a source of arcs cannot be identified, unreliable performance means the breaker should not be trusted.
Failure to Trip on Test
All AFCI breakers have a button that can manually simulate an arc fault. Pushing this button is expected to instantly trip the breaker. If this test fails, the breaker is defective and must be replaced immediately.
Circuit Problems Persist
If lights are flickering, outlets are malfunctioning, or other odd electrical behavior persists, the AFCI may not be detecting an arc fault. Problems like this warrant thorough electrical testing.
Signs of Overheating
Heat damage or scorching around the breaker, burned wiring, or melted insulation can indicate a breaker failed to do its job. Any evidence of overheating should be a red flag.
Age Over 10 Years
AFCI breakers do have a typical lifespan. Although robust models can last 15-20 years, most sources recommend replacing any AFCI older than 10 years as a precaution.
| Sign | Indication |
|---|---|
| Nuisance tripping | Unreliable performance, cannot be trusted |
| Fails manual arc fault test | Breaker is defective, replace immediately |
| Electrical problems persist | May be failing to detect arc faults |
| Evidence of overheating | Breaker may have failed to interrupt arc fault |
| Age over 10 years | Near end of expected lifespan, replace as precaution |
What Should You Do if You Suspect an Issue?
If you notice any of the warning signs described above, follow these steps:
Stop Using the Circuit
Until the breaker is inspected or replaced, stop using the affected circuit. Unplug devices and only turn on essential loads. This limits exposure in the event of fire or further electrical damage.
Test the Breaker
Use the manufacturer’s instructions to locate the test button on the AFCI breaker and press it. The breaker should immediately trip off. If it fails this test, replacement is required.
Inspect for Damage
With the circuit de-energized, remove the breaker and visually inspect for any signs of overheating or damage. Contact an electrician if you have any concerns over the breaker or wiring conditions.
Contact an Electrician
Replacing an AFCI should be done by a qualified electrician, both for safety and to ensure the new unit is properly installed and tested. Notify your electrician promptly about a potentially defective AFCI.
Replacement Considerations
When purchasing a new AFCI breaker, keep the following guidance in mind:
Match Electrical System
Choose a unit listed as compatible with your home’s electrical system. This includes matching amperage, number of poles, and voltage type. Installing the wrong breaker can create a hazard.
Meet Code Requirements
Select an AFCI model that complies with the same NEC requirements as the version being replaced. Usually the new unit also needs to be an AFCI, but newer designs can sometimes be an upgrade option.
Check Warranty
The warranty length often reflects the expected lifespan of that particular AFCI model. Avoid choices with very short warranties, and prefer models that offer warranties of 10 years or longer.
Consider Smart Capability
Some modern AFCI breakers can connect to your home’s Wi-Fi network or a centralized monitoring system. This can provide remote diagnostics and alerts for added convenience and safety.
Hire an Electrician
Only qualified electricians should install or replace an AFCI breaker. Attempting to DIY this repair risks getting an incompatible model or creating wiring errors and safety hazards.
Preventative Maintenance
To maximize AFCI safety and longevity, suppliers recommend a few simple preventative maintenance steps:
Test Breakers Annually
Use the manufacturer’s instructions to locate the test button on each AFCI breaker. Press this button once per year to verify the breaker still trips properly. Catching failures early improves safety.
Exercise Breakers Periodically
Along with testing, trip each AFCI breaker fully off and back on a couple times per year. This cycling helps maintain the internal switching components and prevents seizing from long-term inactivity.
Avoid Moisture and Debris
Keep the breaker panel area clean and dry to prevent corrosion or damage to AFCI components. Address any plumbing leaks or other moisture sources promptly.
Replace After 10 Years
Treat AFCI breakers as having about a 10 year lifespan. Have an electrician replace any units over 10 years old as a precaution, even if still functional. Newer upgrades often enhance reliability and safety.
Buy Quality Products
Seeking out reputable AFCI product lines from trusted manufacturers will provide better protection and longevity. Avoid low quality off-brand breakers that likely won’t live up to their ratings.
Conclusion
Arc fault circuit interrupter breakers are invaluable for electrical fire safety. But like any complex electronic device, they can degrade and malfunction over the years. Allowing a defective AFCI to remain in place is asking for trouble. By understanding the risks of breaker failure and learning to identify problems early, you can take prompt action for repair or replacement. Protect your home by knowing the warning signs, performing preventative maintenance, and hiring a professional electrician to address any AFCI issues. Keeping these specialized breakers in peak operating condition enhances fire safety and provides much needed peace of mind.