When installing a swing set in your backyard, one of the most important considerations is what type of protective surfacing to put down around the play area. Having a proper surface under and around the swings can help prevent injuries from falls and make the area safer and more enjoyable for kids. There are several options for swing set surfacing, each with their own pros and cons. In this article, we will examine the most popular types of protective surfacing for swing sets and help determine which is the best option for your needs.
Page Contents
Safety Considerations
The main purpose of having a protective surface under and around a swing set is to cushion falls and prevent serious injuries. When children fall from a swing or play structure, the landing surface they hit can make a big difference in the severity of the injury. Hard surfaces like concrete or packed dirt can result in fractures, head injuries, or other trauma from high-impact falls. Installing proper surfacing helps absorb the shock of impacts and protects kids from harm.
Some key factors to consider when choosing a swing set surfacing material include:
– Shock absorption – The surface should be able to cushion falls from the maximum height of your swing set. Materials like rubber, sand, or bark chips provide impact attenuation.
– Durability – The surfacing must withstand frequent use and weather exposure without packing down or becoming uneven over time. Long-lasting materials will maintain safety.
– Drainage – Good drainage is necessary to prevent puddles or muddy conditions. Surfacing that drains well is safer and more usable after rain.
– Low maintenance – Opt for materials that won’t require frequent upkeep or replacement to maintain safety over many years.
– Accessibility – Look for surfacing that is wheelchair friendly and easy to navigate for children with disabilities.
– Cost – Budget-friendly options are ideal, as you will likely need a large quantity of surfacing material.
Keeping these factors in mind will help you select a swing set surface that is protective, functional and provides lasting value.
Types of Swing Set Surfacing
Loose Fill Materials
Loose fill surfacing refers to particles poured or spread across the surface under and around playground equipment like swings. These materials are not solid or bonded together, allowing drainage and shock absorption. Common loose fill options include:
Sand
– Very shock absorbent and cushioning
– Provides good drainage
– May require frequent raking to maintain proper depth
– Can be dusty when dry or muddy when wet
– Low cost
Pea Gravel
– Naturally occurring small, smooth stones
– Allow water drainage, won’t get muddy
– Requires edging to contain gravel
– Installation is straightforward
– Needs to be raked level frequently
– Not ideal for wheelchairs due to difficulty rolling over
Shredded Bark Mulch
– Made from shredded tree bark
– Cushions falls well when deep enough
– Retains some moisture, minimizing dust
– Can be displaced by use over time
– Must maintain proper depth for safety
– Relatively low cost
Rubber Mulch
– Shredded rubber from tires
– Excellent shock absorption
– Doesn’t easily compact or erode
– Lasts well for years
– Higher cost than traditional mulch
– May have slight odor initially
Wood Chips
– Made from chipped/shredded wood
– Reasonably good impact absorption
– Tend to scatter and require frequent raking
– Can rot over time, requiring replacement
– Low cost option
Poured-in-Place Surfaces
Poured-in-place (PIP) surfaces refer to materials that are liquid when installed and then cure to form a unitary shock-absorbing surface. Common types include:
Poured Rubber
– Two-part urethane and rubber mix
– Installs as liquid then cures as solid surface
– Excellent shock absorption and accessibility
– Withstands weather well
– Seamless with no cracks for drainage
– High cost for material and installation
Poured Polyurethane
– Two-part polymer and rubber mixture
– Cures into unified shock-absorbent surface
– Maintains level surface with no erosion
– Extremely durable long-term
– High cost for system
EPDM Rubber
– Ethylene propylene diene rubber
– Applied as liquid, cures into rubber surface
– Superior shock absorption and stability
– Expensive upfront cost
– Seamless, non-porous and smooth
– Wheelchair accessible
Synthetic Turf
– Artificial grass surface
– Cushioned backing provides shock absorption
– Withstands heavy use without compacting
– No maintenance needed
– Won’t erode or scatter like loose fill
– May degrade in sunlight over time
– Won’t accommodate wheelchairs well
– Relatively high cost
Foam Mats
Interlocking foam mats are another option for surfacing swing sets. Key attributes include:
– Made from closed cell foam
– Pieces connect together over area
– Excellent shock absorbing qualities
– Easy DIY installation option
– Can be uneven if pieces shift
– Not accessible for wheelchairs
– Cost varies by thickness and size
Installation Guidelines
Proper installation of your chosen surfacing is crucial to creating a safe play area. Here are some key guidelines:
– Extend surfacing at least 6 feet in all directions from equipment
– For swings, surfacing should extend twice the height of the top crossbar both front and back
– Minimum depths range from 6-12 inches depending on material
– Ensure drainage slopes away from equipment – 1-2% grade recommended
– Contain loose materials with edging or borders
– Follow manufacturer instructions carefully for poured-in-place
– Rake and level surface frequently, maintain proper depths
– Check for compaction and rake up displaced material
– Remove trip hazards from surfacing over time
Cost Comparison
| Surface Type | Average Cost per Square Foot |
|---|---|
| Shredded Rubber Mulch | $1.15 |
| Pea Gravel | $1.10 |
| Sand | $0.95 |
| Wood Chips | $0.75 |
| Poured Rubber | $4.50 |
| Synthetic Turf | $3.00 |
| Foam Mats | $2.25 |
Prices can vary based on supplier, materials, and installation requirements. Larger surface areas will incur higher total costs.
Recommendations by Age Group
The best swing set surface may differ depending on the primary age group using the play area:
Toddlers (under 4 years)
For very young children just learning to use swings or play equipment, rubber mulch, poured rubber, or foam mats provide the softest landing. Their lighter weight makes shock absorption especially important. Make sure surface is wheelchair friendly for kids with mobility devices.
Young Kids (ages 4-8)
School-age children can benefit from the cushioning of materials like shredded bark mulch, pea gravel, or poured polyurethane. Ensure proper edging and containment of loose fill. This group may play more rambunctiously and require frequent raking/leveling.
Older Kids (over 8 years)
For bigger, active kids, options like wood chips, sand, or synthetic turf are sufficiently cushioning while accommodating more intensive play. Allow extra distance from swings for safety. Durability and drainage become more important for this demographic. Periodic refreshing of materials may be needed.
All-Ages Accessible
To accommodate a range of ages including younger and disabled users, poured rubber, EPDM rubber, or foam mats provide the safest options. Ensure surfaces are wheelchair friendly and enable all children to enjoy the swings.
Key Considerations by Material
| Material | Shock Absorption | Durability | Drainage | Maintenance | Accessibility | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sand | Very Good | Fair | Excellent | Frequent | Poor | Low |
| Wood Chips | Good | Poor | Good | High | Fair | Very Low |
| Pea Gravel | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Moderate | Poor | Low |
| Shredded Rubber | Excellent | Very Good | Good | Low | Good | Moderate |
| Poured Rubber | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Minimal | Excellent | High |
| Synthetic Turf | Good | Good | Poor | Minimal | Poor | Moderate |
Conclusion
When choosing a surfacing material for your swing set, consider all the options along with your budget, children’s ages, accessibility needs, and your yard environment. Ultimately there is no single “best” option. Sand, wood chips or pea gravel offer good safety at lower cost for most home settings. Poured rubber or rubber mulch provide maximum protection with less maintenance. Synthetic turf or foam mats give a uniform appearance. Work with a reputable installer to ensure proper preparation, installation, and containment appropriate for your selected material. With the right surfacing in place, you can rest assured knowing your swing set area provides a safe, fun place for kids to play for years to come.