Selecting the right heating system for a shop or commercial space is crucial for providing a comfortable environment for customers and employees while also managing energy costs. The most efficient heater will depend on factors like the size of the space, climate, usage patterns, and budget. Key considerations include upfront costs, operating costs, maintenance needs, safety, and the type of heat distribution.
Page Contents
Types of Heaters for Shops
There are several main types of heaters commonly used in shops and commercial spaces:
Forced Air Furnace
Forced air furnaces work by heating air and distributing it through ductwork. This allows heat to be spread evenly throughout the space. Key advantages are relatively low upfront costs, compatibility with central air conditioning, and the ability to control different temperature zones. Downsides are duct losses and noise from moving air.
Radiant Heaters
Radiant heat systems work by heating surfaces like floors, walls, or ceilings, which then radiate heat. Types of radiant heat include in-floor hydronic systems, electric radiant panels, and gas-fired infrared heaters. Benefits arecomfortable, draft-free warmth and high efficiency. Installation costs can be higher.
Heat Pumps
Heat pumps move heat between indoor and outdoor coils. They can provide both heating and AC from one system. Heat pumps have become much more efficient in cold climates. Pros are versatility, energy savings, and low operating costs. Cons are moderate upfront costs.
Electric Resistance Heaters
Portable electric heaters or electric furnaces convert 100% of energy to heat. Benefits are low purchase costs, easy installation, and zoned heating ability. Downsides are higher operating costs and less effective heating in large spaces.
Heat Distribution
In addition to the heating unit, the method of heat delivery impacts efficiency:
Forced Air
Forced air systems distribute heated air through ductwork. Good for heating quickly, but subject to losses through ducts. Requires a blower to move air.
Hydronic Radiant
Hydronic systems circulate hot water from a boiler through pipes and radiators/tubing. Provides very even, comfortable heat. Higher efficiency than forced air overall.
Electric Radiant
Electric radiant heat uses electric cables or panels to heat surfaces. Easy to retrofit into existing spaces. Low maintenance and good zone control.
Infrared Heaters
Infrared heaters warm objects directly using radiant energy. Good for spot heating areas like patios. Very energy efficient.
Key Factors in Selecting a Commercial Heater
Several variables specific to your shop should guide the heating system selection:
Size of the Space
Larger, open floor plans generally require a powerful central heating system like a forced air furnace or boiler system. Smaller shops may rely on ductless mini-splits, electric radiators, or infrared heaters.
Usage Patterns and Hours
Intermittently heated spaces like warehouses can use heaters only when occupied. Spaces with consistent hours are better suited to central systems. Occupancy sensors can maximize efficiency.
Climate and Temperatures
The severity of winters impacts the heating output and efficiency required. Heat pumps work best in moderately cold climates. Very cold climates may require gas furnaces or infrared heaters.
Zoning Needs
If you need different temperatures in separate areas, forced air and hydronic systems allow better zoning control. Electric heaters can also provide room-by-room temperature adjustments.
Upfront vs Operating Costs
Electric resistance heaters have low purchase costs but high operating costs. Heat pumps and high efficiency furnaces cost more upfront but provide better long term efficiency.
Available Fuels and Power
Fuel availability often determines suitable heating systems. Gas furnaces require natural gas lines. Heat pumps need adequate electrical systems. Infrared uses propane in many cases.
HVAC System Integration
If adding cooling later, choose heating systems compatible with AC like forced air or heat pumps. Hydronic and radiant systems can also integrate with cooling.
Maintenance Requirements
Central heating systems have annual maintenance needs like filter changes, inspections, and tune-ups. Electric and infrared heaters require little to no maintenance.
Safety and Building Codes
Natural gas systems must meet plumbing and ventilation codes. Electrical heaters have plug load and circuit requirements. Work with qualified professionals for code compliance.
Most Efficient Heater Options for Shops
Based on performance, operating costs, and suitability for commercial spaces, these are among the most efficient heating solutions:
1. High Efficiency Furnaces
High efficiency or condensing furnaces convert over 90% of fuel to heat. Advanced heat exchangers reuse waste heat from exhaust gases. ENERGY STAR rated models indicate the highest efficiency. Ideal for centralized heating in any climate.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
2. Ductless Mini-Split Heat Pumps
Ductless heat pumps provide highly efficient electric heating and cooling. The compressor and heat exchanger are located outside, with indoor heads in each zone. Ideal for high efficiency retrofits or additions.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
3. Infrared Heaters
Infrared heaters use radiant energy to heat people and objects directly. Gas-fired versions offer greenhouse gas savings compared to propane. Great for spot heating.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
4. Hydronic Radiant Heating
Hydronic systems use hot water circulated through radiators, in-floor tubing, or radiant panels. Provides very comfortable, draft-free warmth. Works with high efficiency condensing boilers.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
|
Key Considerations for Efficiency
To maximize energy savings in a commercial heating system:
- Have load calculations performed to properly size the heating system
- Insulate the space thoroughly to reduce heat loss
- Seal air leaks throughout the building envelope
- Install a programmable thermostat and set back temperatures at night
- Group heaters or heating zones to match usage patterns
- Add occupancy sensors in warehouses or storage areas
- Service heaters annually for peak performance
- Select ENERGY STAR certified heating equipment
Conclusion
Modern high efficiency furnaces, mini-split ductless heat pumps, infrared heaters, and hydronic radiant systems offer the best efficiency for heating most shops and commercial spaces. Choosing the right system depends on the specific requirements of your building, heating needs, and budget. Work with qualified HVAC professionals for proper sizing, load calculations, and installation. Investing in an efficient heating system will provide lower operating costs, comfort, and reliability for years to come.