Controlling weeds in your garden or lawn area can be tricky, especially if you want to avoid harming surrounding flowers and other desirable plants. Many common weed killers are non-selective, meaning they will kill any plant they contact. However, there are some options that can selectively target weeds while leaving flowers unharmed. The key is understanding what makes a weed killer selective versus non-selective and choosing the right active ingredients and application methods for your needs.
Page Contents
What Makes a Weed Killer Selective?
Weed killers containing the active ingredients glyphosate, glufosinate ammonium, or diquat are non-selective herbicides. This means they interrupt biological processes that are common to all plants, so they will kill grasses, flowers, vegetables, and any other vegetation they touch.
Selective weed killers work differently. Rather than targeting processes all plants need to survive, they exploit biological differences between plant species. This allows them to kill certain unwanted plants while leaving desirable species unharmed.
Some common ways weed killers can be made selective include:
- Using a growth regulator that only affects certain plant families – Growth regulators disrupt plant hormones involved in cell growth and division. Specific regulators can target broadleaf plants while leaving grasses unaffected, or vice versa.
- Taking advantage of waxy leaf coatings – Some weeds have waxy or hairy leaves that repel herbicides. Coating the leaves of desirable plants with a protected film before spraying can shield them.
- Targeting specific enzyme systems – Each plant species has enzymes that are unique or genetically distinct from other species. Herbicides can be designed to inhibit enzyme activity in weeds but not crops or flowers.
- Exploiting differences in plant metabolism – The ways plants take up and translocate herbicides to their roots and leaves can vary between species. Some weed killers bind tightly to soils to avoid uptake by established plants.
Matching the right mode of selective action to your particular weed problems is key for avoiding flower damage.
Weed Killer Options That Spare Flowers
Here are some selective weed killer products and active ingredients to consider for controlling weeds without harming nearby ornamentals:
2,4-D
2,4-D is a growth regulator selective herbicide that mimics the plant growth hormone auxin. It works by overstimulating affected plants’ growth processes, leading to uncontrolled division and growth that destroys vascular tissues.
2,4-D products are effective at controlling broadleaf weeds like dandelions, plantain, and wild violet in turfgrass. It can also control brush and woody plants in rangeland and pasture settings.
Flowers that 2,4-D spares include:
- Petunias
- Marigolds
- Zinnias
- Roses
- Daisies
- Iris
- Daylilies
Some examples of 2,4-D products include:
- Ortho Weed B Gon
- Spectracide Weed Stop
- Green Light Amine 2,4-D
Dicamba
Like 2,4-D, dicamba is an auxin mimic herbicide that selectively controls broadleaf weeds without harming grasses. It is effective on many of the same weeds as 2,4-D, including dandelions, clover, bindweed, and wild violet.
Dicamba can be sprayed around flowers such as:
- Marigolds
- Petunias
- Begonias
- Roses
- Lilies
- Irises
Some dicamba weed killer products include:
- Ortho Weed B Gon Chickweed, Clover & Oxalis Killer
- Bonide Weed Beater Ultra
- Spectracide Weed Stop for Lawns Plus Crabgrass Killer
Oryzalin
Unlike the growth regulator herbicides above, oryzalin is a pre-emergent herbicide that controls weeds before they emerge from seed. It inhibits cell division and growth in germinating weed seeds, preventing root and shoot development.
When applied as a pre-emergent, oryzalin can control annual grasses like crabgrass and annual bluegrass as well as small-seeded broadleaf weeds. Established perennials like flowers and shrubs are unaffected since only weed seeds exposed to the chemical are controlled.
Some oryzalin products to use around ornamentals:
- Surflan AS Specialty Herbicide
- Ortho Weed B Gon Max Plus Crabgrass Control
- Green Light Amaze Grass & Weed Preventer
Glyphosate-Based Products Labeled for Flowers
While glyphosate is normally non-selective, some products containing glyphosate are specifically labeled for weed control in flower beds. Partial selectivity is achieved by using a waxy protective film on desirable plants or adding a secondary active ingredient to target specific weeds.
Two products labeled for flowers are:
- Roundup Ready-to-Use Weed & Grass Killer III
- Compare-N-Save Concentrate Grass & Weed Killer
Be sure to read labels closely and coat flowers with protective film before application as directed. Test on a small area first.
Vinegar-Based Herbicides
Herbicides made from 20% acetic acid vinegar provide limited control of young weeds and may spare established flowers. However, they often require repeat applications. Some flower-safe vinegar weed killers include:
- Garden Safe Weed & Grass Killer
- Natural Armor Weed & Grass Killer
- Southern Ag Natural Crabgrass & Weed Killer
Vinegar herbicides work best on soft-bodied annual weeds less than 3-4 inches tall. Perennials and woody plants require higher concentrations or repeat applications. Test first on small areas to avoid flower damage.
How to Apply Selective Weed Killers Around Flowers
When using selective weed killers near ornamentals, follow some basic guidelines for best results:
- Read herbicide labels thoroughly – Make sure the product is labeled for use in flower beds and follow all instructions.
- Spray on a calm day – Windy conditions increase risk of spray drift contacting flowers.
- Use a spray shield – Plastic guards help block spray from reaching flowers.
- Spray weeds selectively – Use a wand applicator for targeted spraying rather than broadcast spraying.
- Know the growth stage – Apply herbicides like oryzalin at the right time to control newly germinating weeds.
- Work around the base of plants – Hand pull weeds around sensitive flowers rather than risking exposure.
Also be aware that even selective herbicides may damage certain species and cultivars. Always check for flower tolerance before widespread use. Common sensitive flowers include:
- Buttercups
- Legumes
- Crucifers
- Sweet peas
- Pansies
- Violas
Avoid spraying these flowers with any weed killers or test thoroughly on small areas first. It is also best to weed manually around susceptible flowers.
Key Considerations When Choosing Flower-Safe Weed Killers
Keep the following tips in mind when selecting weed killers to use around ornamentals:
- Know your target weeds – Match the herbicide mode of action to problem weeds.
- Select for flower species – Check that the product is labeled for use around specific flowers grown.
- Consider application method – Sprays may drift while granules stay put.
- Time applications carefully – Move flowers or use shields to prevent exposure.
- Read the label – Follow all instructions and precautions.
- More is not better – Stick to recommended rates.
- Test on small areas – Check for flower sensitivity before widespread use.
- Combine methods – Integrate chemical controls with hand weeding, mulching, and cultivation.
Choosing the right weed killer along with proper application techniques will allow you to safely combat weeds without sacrificing the beauty of your flower beds and gardens. Reaching a healthy balance through integrated weed management is key.
Comparison of Common Flower-Safe Weed Killers
| Herbicide | Mode of Action | When to Apply | Key Weeds Controlled | Flowers Spared |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2,4-D | Growth regulator | Post-emergence | Dandelions, plantain, wild violet | Roses, irises, marigolds, zinnias |
| Dicamba | Growth regulator | Post-emergence | Bindweed, clover, wild violet | Lilies, petunias, roses |
| Oryzalin | Pre-emergent | Pre-emergence | Crabgrass, annual bluegrass | Established perennials, shrubs |
| Vinegar | Non-selective contact | Young weeds | Annuals, seedlings | Limited use around established flowers |
Organic Weed Control Options
For those wishing to avoid synthetic chemicals around flowers, some organic approaches to weed control include:
- Corn gluten meal – Pre-emergent weed control made from corn byproducts. Must be applied before weeds sprout.
- Soap-based herbicides – Made from plant oils and designed to penetrate soft weed tissues.
- Acetic acid – Higher strength vinegar that provides contact kill of young weeds.
- Boiling water – Kills weeds on contact. Best for cracks in walkways and patios.
- Flame weeding – Uses heat to disrupt plant tissues and dehydrate weeds.
- Solarization – Clear plastic sheets heat soil to kill seeds and roots.
- Manual removal – Hand weeding and hoeing are traditional organic methods.
- Mulching – Blocks light to prevent weed germination and growth.
Multiple applications are often needed for best control. But these organic options avoid chemicals around ornamentals. An integrated program is ideal.
Conclusion
Controlling weeds without harming flowers is possible with the right choice of selective herbicides, proper application techniques, and integrated organic strategies. By understanding weed and flower biology and exploiting differences between species, products can selectively target unwanted plants. Growth regulator herbicides, pre-emergents, vinegar solutions, and shielded glyphosate preparations allow flexibility in managing weeds in ornamental plantings. Combined with manual and cultural controls, you can successfully keep gardens and landscapes weed-free without sacrificing beauty. Test products thoroughly, read labels carefully, and time applications properly for effective, flower-safe weed control.