When it comes to maintaining hedges and bushes around your property, having a quality hedge trimmer can make the job much easier. The two main types of hedge trimmers are gas powered and electric. Both have their pros and cons and are better suited to different situations. Knowing the key differences between gas and electric hedge trimmers will help you decide which is the best choice for your needs.
Page Contents
Gas Hedge Trimmers
Gas powered hedge trimmers have long been a popular choice for professionals and homeowners with large properties and extensive hedges to maintain. Here are some of the main benefits of gas hedge trimmers:
Power
Gas hedge trimmers are more powerful than electric models. They have high-torque motors that can cut through thick branches and handle overgrown bushes with ease. This makes them ideal for tackling large hedges.
Extended runtime
The gas motor provides continuous power and you aren’t limited by battery life. This allows you to work for as long as needed to trim all your hedges in one session.
Consistent performance
Gas engines deliver consistent cutting power and performance regardless of the thickness and density of growth. Their power output doesn’t drop off like some electric models when the going gets tough.
Versatility
Most gas hedge trimmers can also convert into grass trimmers or edgers with the right attachments. This makes them versatile 3-in-1 yard tools.
Low long-term costs
You don’t need to buy replacement batteries every few years like with electric trimmers. Gas engines just need regular maintenance like oil changes and air filter replacements. This generally works out cheaper in the long run.
Better for larger properties
With their power and unlimited runtime, gas hedge trimmers are the best choice for trimming hedges on properties of 1 acre or more. You can tackle hundreds of feet of hedges without stopping.
Electric Hedge Trimmers
While gas models dominate the professional landscaping market, electric hedge trimmers have quite a few advantages that make them a great choice for some homeowners:
Lightweight design
Cordless electric trimmers weigh much less than gas trimmers. This makes them much easier to maneuver and less tiring to use for extended trimming sessions.
Quieter operation
Electric hedge trimmers produce significantly less noise pollution than loud gas engines. This makes them better for use in residential areas.
Low maintenance
With no engine, air filter or oil to worry about, electric trimmers just require occasional blade sharpening and lubrication. You don’t have to deal with the messy maintenance of gas motors.
Lower upfront cost
Quality electric trimmers typically cost $50 to $100 less than gas-powered models with comparable cutting length and power. The lower initial price makes them attractive for homeowners looking for an affordable option.
Better for smaller hedges
While limited runtime precludes electric models from all-day professional use, they can handle typical-sized residential hedges on a single charge. For 100 feet of hedge or less, they get the job done without any hassle.
Cleaner operation
Without noxious gas fumes, electric trimmers are nicer to operate for longer periods. There’s also no chance of spilling fuel or oil during refueling.
Key Considerations
When deciding between gas and electric hedge trimmers, here are some important factors to consider:
Amount of trimming required
For less than an hour total of trimming time per charge, electric works well. For large properties with hundreds of feet of hedges, gas delivers the unlimited runtime needed.
Power requirements
Thick old hedges with dense branches call for the extra power and torque of gas. More modern bushy hedges can be handled by electric.
Noise limitations
If you have close neighbors, electric hedge trimmers generate less noise and are better suited for residential areas. Gas trimmers are very loud when running.
Environmental concerns
Electric trimmers have no direct emissions and are better for the environment. Gas trimmers require fuel and emit fumes.
Safety issues
Cordless electric designs eliminate any risk of cutting the power cord while working. Gas models need careful handling to avoid burns or other injuries from hot mufflers.
Maintenance expectations
If you aren’t very mechanically inclined, electric trimmers require much less maintenance and are a better option. Gas trimmers need regular engine care.
Recommendations
When making a choice between gas and electric hedge trimmers, consider these typical recommendations:
Electric for:
– Trimming less than 100 feet of lighter foliage
– Homeowners needing an affordable and easy maintenance option
– Use in noise-sensitive residential areas
– People wanting greater safety and convenience
Gas for:
– Trimming over 200 feet of thicker, woody hedges
– Professional landscapers and large properties
– People wanting maximum power and unlimited runtime
– Use on rural larger properties away from residences
– Homeowners comfortable maintaining gas engines
Comparisons
To help summarize the key differences, here is a comparison table of gas vs electric hedge trimmers:
| Feature | Gas Hedge Trimmer | Electric Hedge Trimmer |
|---|---|---|
| Power | More torque for cutting thick branches | Less power but adequate for lighter growth |
| Runtime | Unlimited runtime from gas motor | Up to 1 hour runtime per charge |
| Noise Level | Noisy gas engines in the 95-100 dB range | Typically 70-80dB for quieter operation |
| Weight | Heavier units around 10-12 lbs | Lighter weight around 6-8 lbs |
| Safety | Risk of burns from hot mufflers | No hot parts or power cords |
| Maintenance | Require engine care and filter cleaning | Minimal maintenance besides blade sharpening |
| Cost | $200 to $400 for most models | $100 to $300 for most models |
As you can see, each type of hedge trimmer has pros and cons that make them better suited to particular users and situations. Consider your specific trimming needs, property size, budget, and maintenance preferences when deciding on gas or electric.
Recommend Products
Based on overall performance, features, reliability, and owner reviews, here are my top recommended gas and electric hedge trimmers to consider:
Gas hedge trimmers
Hitachi CG22EAP2SL – commercial-grade 21.1cc 2-stroke engine, 22″ dual-action laser-cut blades, rear rotating handle
Echo HC-151 – professional-grade 21.2cc 2-cycle engine, 20″ blade, comfort handle design
Husqvarna 122HD60 – 21.7cc 2-cycle engine, 22″ diamond ground blade, smart start system
Electric hedge trimmers
Greenworks 20V hedge trimmer – 20V lithium battery, 22″ hardened steel blades, lightweight at just 6 lbs
Ryobi 40V – high power 40V lithium battery, 22″ precision ground blades, rotating rear handle
Black & Decker 20V MAX – long lasting 20V MAX lithium battery, 22” dual action blades, excellent value
No matter which type you choose, always look for ergonomic handles, blade tip protectors, easy start systems, and warranties of at least 2 years for gas models or 5 years for electric. Proper care will ensure your hedge trimmer provides many years of reliable service.
Conclusion
For light duty residential use, electric hedge trimmers provide an affordable and quieter alternative to gas models. But when extended runtime and maximum power are needed, gas-powered units are still the best choice. Evaluate your specific hedge trimming requirements and property size to decide which is right for you. With proper use and regular maintenance, either a quality gas or electric hedge trimmer can deliver years of reliable performance keeping your hedges neatly trimmed.