When it comes to keeping your spa clean and sanitized, you have two main options for sanitizers: bromine and chlorine. Both bromine and chlorine are effective at killing bacteria and algae in hot tub water. However, there are some key differences between these two chemicals that make bromine a better choice for most spa owners.
In this article, we’ll go over the pros and cons of using bromine vs. chlorine in spas. We’ll look at how they work, their effectiveness, ease of use, safety, and cost. By the end, you should have a good understanding of why bromine is generally considered the best sanitizer for hot tubs.
Page Contents
How Bromine Works in Spas
Bromine belongs to the halogen family of chemicals. When used in spa water, it forms hypobromous acid and hypobromite ions. These bromine species kill bacteria and algae by oxidizing their cell membranes, effectively destroying the contaminants.
Here’s a quick overview of how bromine sanitizes spa water:
- Bromine tablets or granules dissolve slowly when added to the hot tub.
- This releases free available bromine into the water.
- The bromine reacts with water to form hypobromous acid and hypobromite ions.
- The hypobromous acid and hypobromite ions sanitize the water by killing bacteria, viruses, and algae.
- After killing contaminants, bromine reverts back to bromide ions which repeat the cycle.
The hypobromous acid is especially effective at sanitizing hot tubs since it remains active even in high temperatures and pH conditions. This makes bromine a reliable sanitizer for spa water.
How Chlorine Works in Spas
Like bromine, chlorine belongs to the halogen chemical group. When added to water, it forms hypochlorous acid and hypochlorite ions.
Here is the chlorine sanitizing process:
- Chlorine tablets or granules dissolve when placed in the spa.
- This releases free chlorine into the water.
- The free chlorine reacts with water and forms hypochlorous acid and hypochlorite ions.
- These chlorine species destroy bacteria and algae by damaging their cell membranes and structures.
- Used up chlorine reforms into chloride ions which can repeat the cycle.
The hypochlorous acid is an effective sanitizer and oxidizer. However, it is more prone to degradation from high temperatures and pH compared to bromine.
Bromine vs. Chlorine: Effectiveness and Ease of Use
When comparing the sanitizing effectiveness of bromine vs. chlorine, bromine comes out as the clear winner for hot tubs and spas.
Here are some of the reasons bromine is more effective than chlorine:
- Bromine remains active across a wider pH range (6.8-8.0) whereas chlorine is impacted by pH fluctuations.
- Hypobromous acid is more stable than hypochlorous acid in high temperatures.
- Bromine has a lower evaporation rate than chlorine in hot water.
- It takes lower levels of bromine (2.0-4.0 ppm) than free chlorine (3.0-5.0 ppm) to effectively sanitize spas.
- Bromine does not degrade as rapidly from UV exposure as chlorine.
In terms of ease of use, bromine also has some advantages:
- Bromine tablets dissolve slowly over time, providing a steady release of sanitizer.
- Brominating tablets can simply be placed in a floater or feeder. Less mixing with water is required.
- Maintaining the ideal 2.0-4.0 ppm level is straightforward with bromine tablets.
- With chlorine, the tablets must be dissolved rapidly in water to provide the immediate sanitizing action.
Overall, the controlled release and wide operating range of bromine makes it simpler to maintain the right sanitizer levels in spas.
Bromine vs. Chlorine: Safety
When evaluating pool and spa sanitizers, safety is a crucial factor. Both bromine and chlorine can cause irritation or damage if mishandled or accidentally ingested in large amounts.
However, bromine has a better safety profile at the dosage levels used in hot tubs:
- Bromine has a lower vapor pressure than chlorine, making it less prone to forming respiratory irritants.
- It is less reactive than chlorine, reducing the risk of chemical burns.
- At typical spa concentrations, bromine does not irritate eyes or skin for most people.
- Proper bromine levels (2-4 ppm) are safe for pregnant women whereas chlorine can be more irritating.
- Bromine has a medicinal smell at high concentrations but is odorless at proper sanitizing levels.
Additionally, bromine does not degrade into potentially hazardous disinfection byproducts like chlorine. Overall, spa users are less likely to experience safety issues like irritation, breathing discomfort, or unpleasant odors with bromine compared to chlorine.
Bromine vs. Chlorine: Cost Comparison
When comparing the costs of operating a spa with bromine vs. chlorine, bromine comes out as the more economical option in most cases.
Here are some ways bromine can save on operating costs:
- The lower dosage requirements mean spending less on bromine tablets overall.
- Bromine does not degrade as fast from UV and heat, reducing the chemical consumption.
- With a more stable pH range, extra acid or base is not needed to adjust alkalinity.
- The slow-dissolving tablets last 2-3 weeks longer than rapidly dissolving chlorine tablets.
- For new spa fills, bromine can build up a residual faster than chlorine, saving initial chemical costs.
While the upfront costs of a bromine floater or feeder are higher, the long term savings on chemicals typically offsets this expense. Below is a cost comparison table for operating a 350 gallon spa for 1 year with bromine vs. chlorine:
1 Year Hot Tub Chemical Costs
| Costs | Bromine | Chlorine |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Floater/Feeder | $89.99 | $39.99 |
| Sanitizing Tablets | $224.85 (x3 25lb buckets) | $299.80 (x4 25lb buckets) |
| pH Adjustment Chemicals | $47.96 | $119.88 |
| Total Annual Costs | $362.80 | $459.67 |
As the table shows, the costs of operating a hot tub with bromine for 1 year is around $100 less than using chlorine. While actual costs depend on spa size and use frequency, bromine consistently offers cost savings in the long run.
Additional Pros of Using Bromine in Spas
Beyond the advantages covered already, here are some other benefits of choosing bromine instead of chlorine for hot tubs:
- Does not bleach hair or swimsuits like chlorine.
- More suitable for frequent or daily spa users sensitive to chemicals.
- Lower bromamines levels cause less eye irritation.
- Small daily dose additions can supplement less frequent shock treatments.
- Works well with spa ozone generators to enhance sanitization.
- May be a better choice for indoor or covered spas more prone to chemical off-gassing.
For most people, the properties of bromine are simply more compatible with relaxing hot tub use compared to harsher chlorine. The performance, ease of use, and cost savings of bromine make it the top sanitizer recommended by spa manufacturers and professionals.
Bromine Usage Considerations
While bromine has many advantages, there are a few usage considerations to keep in mind:
- Maintain pH between 7.2-7.8 and alkalinity between 80-150 ppm for optimal performance.
- Change bromine tablets every 2-3 weeks and shock weekly to prevent buildups.
- Use spa testing strips to monitor bromine, pH, and alkalinity levels.
- Start with lower bromine levels for sensitive skin and increase gradually as needed.
- Add bromine tablet disinfectant after shocking the water or replacing cartridges.
- Rinse cartridge filters properly to remove buildup that consumes bromine.
- Safeguard against children or animals accessing bromine floater/feeder.
With responsible use, bromine can provide safe, effective, and affordable sanitization of hot tub water for years of enjoyment.
Conclusion
When weighing all the criteria, bromine emerges as the best sanitizer choice compared to chlorine for hot tubs and spas. The key advantages of using bromine include:
- More stable and effective across high temperatures and pH changes
- Lower required dosage levels
- Simpler maintenance with slow-dissolving tablets
- Less prone to irritate eyes, skin, and lungs
- Does not degrade to hazardous byproducts
- Lower long-term operating costs
By understanding how bromine works and its benefits compared to chlorine, spa owners can make an informed decision. While chlorine is still a decent sanitizer, most experts recommend bromine as the preferred option for its performance, safety, ease of use, and cost profile in hot tub applications. Paying a little more upfront for a bromine feeder will pay off over years of better water quality. If you’re looking to keep your spa water sparking, clean, and inviting year-round, bromine is undoubtedly the best sanitizer available.